• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

Need to remember Willie has Al Boum Photo , very lightly raced, and only beaten 5 lengths in 2021 GC , maybe just a little under cooked , could bounce back to form and maybe an extra gallop somewhere prior to the big day could bring out a better performance

Forget him he’s had his day now.
 
Ahhhhh, poor old Boum. Harsh, but probably true.............have I mentioned Elimay??

Legend of the sport but no point dwelling on the past we’re here to make money after all.
Could someone get elimay added to the exchange? I’d back her at the right price, not interested in the bookie odds.
 
Legend of the sport but no point dwelling on the past we’re here to make money after all.
Could someone get elimay added to the exchange? I’d back her at the right price, not interested in the bookie odds.

You are a hard man to please.........40/1!!
 
I would say that if there was a market of “which race will he end up in” then the Champion Chase would be a huge favourite and rightly so.

i would just really love to see him over that mid trip because as much as I love Energumene I just think he’s stumped against a superstar in Shishkin. It’s hard to comment on it when he hasn’t been run over the mid range trip, for now, in August it looks likely the CC is the destination but I just hope they up him really.

On Minella Indo, I have this theory about the Gold Cup that it bottoms horses out so I never back previous winners. Served me well until ABP came along. I think if Minella Indo was given an ABP style prep I would fancy him more but I just can’t see that happening :moody:

I think the other problem is TOTG I don’t think Cheveley Park would be happy at the current Ryanair champion being pitched in against Shishkin to give Energumene a crack at winning the Ryanair because he would have a better chance winning it. Not an easy sell to Cheveley imo is it?

I agree with AV, well and truly see Energumene and CPS taking on Shishkin unless something happens through the season. As has been discussed, Allaho would be competitive there’s no doubting but on what we’ve seen to date compared with Energumene and CPS, not for me. We can be pretty certain WPM won’t go in single handed against shishkin either, just don’t see Allaho as the option.
 
Agree with a few and fairly happy to throw free bets at the likes of Envoi Allen and Chantry House. They are stepping into open company and deserve the benefit of doubt imo until proven otherwise.

Discounting horses prior to that would be silly and just on Chantry House, there have been plenty of non flashy gold cup winners over the years. They always knew he stayed even in his novice hurdle year and now he’s stepping up (or did on his last run) I wouldn’t discount him so soon.

Edit - forgot to mention I’ll also likely be adding the likes of Imperial Aura and Eklat De Rire but will wait on stable tours and potentially a comeback run before backing. IA bled in the Ryanair so want to see him over that on comeback, EDR is really unexposed and I was happy having him for the RSA, I reckon who could have served it up to Monkfish.
 
Last edited:
40/1 with cash out if that helps

No deal. I admire your persistence to acquire a fellow elimay backer though :welcoming: You’re breaking me Lobos but not at that price.
 
No deal. I admire your persistence to acquire a fellow elimay backer though :welcoming: You’re breaking me Lobos but not at that price.

:biggrin-new::biggrin-new::biggrin-new:Persistence Personified
 
To have any chance he needs to improve his jumping

I rewatched the race the other day and minella indo was making ground at every fence

A plus tard was too slow away from his fences, which also cost him in the previous years ryanair

Yep. He fiddled plenty in the GC and I also think Rachel was riding the race to beat ABP. Had she ignored the fav I think he might just have won, regardless of his minor jumping errors

As things went, he was only one (maybe two) clean jumps away from winning the gold cup imo. He's still young enough and deserves another crack.

I usually ignore those that have tried and failed before but he's one that I really like. There's definitely room for a little improvement and it'll only require marginal gains here and there.
 
The beauty of this forum, having a pre-determined view changed by knowledgable members.

Re Chantry House I’ll make a very ignorant comment but I think he’ll fall short of top table, he make take one or two good contests over here but when the Irish battalion land I think he’ll be short.
No solid argument why just a personal view but I’d be happy to be educated and proved wrong…

Agree with this 100%.
 
I know I keep beating the same drum but anyone who fancies Monkfish to win the Gold Cup just can't ignore Elimay. Monkfish rated 163 and Elimay rated 155. Take into account the 7lb Mares allowance and there's 1lb between them. She looks like she'll stay all day long so the step up will suit. We know she handles Cheltenham and the big occasion, she jumps for fun and she's as game as they come. 6/1 v 40/1. No more comments your honour.

I have a few of issues with this. It's easy to compare ratings against prices and come up with a bet, but it's rarely that simple.

Firstly, course form, Monkfish is 2 from 2 at Cheltenham, Elimay is 0 from 2, whichever way you want to spin it, i.e. the Colreevy form line which I'll come to later.

Secondly, distance, Monkfish has not just won twice at the course, but also both times being over 3m, which leaves him with a lot less to prove than Elimay, who won a weak Mares Chase at Fairyhouse over 2m 5f, the furthest she has run to date.

Thirdly, there is nothing to suggest, in Elimays breeding, that she'll get the Gold Cup trip.

Gave Allaho a fright who murdered them in Ryanair. Easily beat Mount Ida who won at the fez from an impossible position. Smashed Black Tears who won the Mares Hurdle and just got pipped by Colreevy who beat Monkfish out of sight. Just an incredible list.

Form lines, on the Colreevy one, first off Monkfish had a fairly long and tough season prior to that run, and secondly Colreevy's breeding suggested she'd be better suited to a longer trip anyway, so the fact she outbattled Elimay at Cheltenham over shorter is more a nod to how game and good Colreevy is than to how good Elimay is, IMO. On the Mount Ida form line, again, her breeding definitely suggests she'll be better suited over further, and duly obliged at the festival over 3m 2f, but she was hammered by Colreevy the race before that win over 2m 4f, yet only just over 2 lengths down from Elimay at Fairyhouse over an almost identical inadequate trip.

I rarely knock a 40/1 poke, but Elimay has a fair amount of questions to answer for me before I even consider her a Gold Cup runner, let alone the prospect of being competitive in one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Bucks
  • Like
Reactions: Topofthegame2021
COD, re Mount Ida, do you think she'll end up in the Mares Chase or do you think that'll be too short for her ?
 
As already stated i dont fancy Chantry house for the GC at all, but looking through the betting for the King George he's widely 10/1 thats got to be worth a shout, given that the best of the Irish are likely to stay at home.

Id much rather take 10s in the KG than 20s in the GC
 
COD, re Mount Ida, do you think she'll end up in the Mares Chase or do you think that'll be too short for her ?

Too short a trip, IMO. That said, it does depend how weak the race ends up, as even a race that isn't an ideal trip for a horse sometimes class can get them through it, I.e. Colreevy.

I think you have made a good case for Annie MC, who you've spoken about previously, I think, despite the Cheltenham form, has a right chance against her own sex, should she actually make it this time around.
 
Too short a trip, IMO. That said, it does depend how weak the race ends up, as even a race that isn't an ideal trip for a horse sometimes class can get them through it, I.e. Colreevy.

I think you have made a good case for Annie MC, who you've spoken about previously, I think, despite the Cheltenham form, has a right chance against her own sex, should she actually make it this time around.

Agree that MI will struggle over 2 1/2 . Not sure what else she could go for though ? Annie Mc won't beat Elimay but if that one doesn't turn up or she has a bad day then Annie can take advantage.
 
Wish I'd noticed earlier to get more people on but burning victory just dotted up in France at 3/1 in a flat handicap

I sprinted down to the local hills to get 5pts on and even got the two blokes in there to have a few quid on

I was flicking through the deauville races and couldn't believe my eyes when it said WP Mullins next to the fav

Horrible aftertiming i know but thats just paid for a good few Cheltenham bets and im buzzing haha