• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

Honestly Carnage. I think he is going to be one of those that look good over here at places like Sandown and Ascot and then when the Irish serve it up to him, he will wilt. Could be wrong and I hope I'm not because I don't have him for anything. Maybe he was never a 2 miler but Kargese and Kopek put him to the sword quite easily, I can't imagine for one minute he could give Fact To File Or Gaelic Warrior a race, and that's not accounting for the lesser horses in those divisions. I just don't see where he fits into anything as a contender.
I’m far from being his number one fan and he would have been a big loser for me in the Triumph and the Arkle but in fairness he was given a 166 RPR on only his seventh lifetime start. Gaelic took 13 and F2F 8 starts to hit that number. Nothing in life is certain but I’d be as sure as I can be that he is in no way a natural two miler and recognising this plus his age plus his relative inexperience there is potential for significant upsides as he matures and goes out in trip.

Just 7 pounds of improvement puts him hovering around mid 170 RPR territory and any further improvement above that puts him hovering on championship level. I felt last season he was a frame of a horse and very much needed to grow into this frame. This only adds to his potential should he do so (and reports are that this is exactly what he has done). He also has a fair amount of upside in his jumping.

So accounting for perfectly reasonable improvement in jumping, physique, step out in trip and maturity/experience 180+ rprs become a reasonable possibility imo.

Of course plenty of horses fail to develop as hoped or expected but few horses achieve performance ratings like he has while also having so many potential upsides as well.
 
I’m far from being his number one fan and he would have been a big loser for me in the Triumph and the Arkle but in fairness he was given a 166 RPR on only his seventh lifetime start. Gaelic took 13 and F2F 8 starts to hit that number. Nothing in life is certain but I’d be as sure as I can be that he is in no way a natural two miler and recognising this plus his age plus his relative inexperience there is potential for significant upsides as he matures and goes out in trip.

Just 7 pounds of improvement puts him hovering around mid 170 RPR territory and any further improvement above that puts him hovering on championship level. I felt last season he was a frame of a horse and very much needed to grow into this frame. This only adds to his potential should he do so (and reports are that this is exactly what he has done). He also has a fair amount of upside in his jumping.

So accounting for perfectly reasonable improvement in jumping, physique, step out in trip and maturity/experience 180+ rprs become a reasonable possibility imo.

Of course plenty of horses fail to develop as hoped or expected but few horses achieve performance ratings like he has while also having so many potential upsides as well.
Love it RB. That's what makes this place unique. Getting into the nuts and bolts of horses.

I am still not having him though :LOL: (y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rooster Booster
If he bolts up in that it will be a poor renewal.
Pretty sure connections know he’s not a 2 miler at the top level.
He'll be beating the current 2m champion so I would hope it isn't a poor renewal. He's run all his races at around the minimum so still has more to prove over further. Like you said, he too made a race ending error in the Arkle and still finished a good 3rd behind two horses that currently sit high up the CC betting. I still think he may still have a lot to offer over 2m and really want to see him take up his Tingle entry. He won the Henry VIII very easily last year and Sandown really suited him. He's no 50/1 shot to win the CC in view of how open that race looks.
 
He'll be beating the current 2m champion so I would hope it isn't a poor renewal. He's run all his races at around the minimum so still has more to prove over further. Like you said, he too made a race ending error in the Arkle and still finished a good 3rd behind two horses that currently sit high up the CC betting. I still think he may still have a lot to offer over 2m and really want to see him take up his Tingle entry. He won the Henry VIII very easily last year and Sandown really suited him. He's no 50/1 shot to win the CC in view of how open that race looks.
If he bolts up beating IET I’d be amazed.
 
Just to add to that. If we play Donnelly roulette (in my mind anyway) Willie seems keen on giving Salvator Mundi a crack at the Champion Chase and I think even mentioned keeping him apart from his other 2 miles so seems to be giving him every chance to get there. Kitzbuhel's remit is to win the King George and if he does that, there is only one place he is going, Gold Cup. That would leave Lulamba either going to the Ryanair or Aintree if good enough. I don't see him doing anything else so if I was backing him for anything at Cheltenham it would only be the Ryanair
So...
Kitzbuhel ..... K.G. or G.C.
Feel Gut ....... Sup. or Tnrs.
Salvator Mundi ... ch.
 
I never was understanding of Dineen and the fascination behind him. Maybe he was good in the past, but for me in UTA he was stone useless.
Interesting to listen to as a show, but learnt zero.

Think i said the same in here a few times.
The pair are great together but I always enjoyed Gavin Lynch more than Jonny, felt his arguments were much more put together.
 
Hope he does better than OPS. Mind you I’m in the anti Hendo league 😜
Always avoid his horses antepost for Cheltenham now.
Time to retire into a barrel of Petrus 1985
 
  • Like
Reactions: opatcho
Lulamba is the last of the hendo horses for me, but I don’t know why. He isn’t a shishkin, or a alitor, or a sprinter, etc
I guess there’s hope he’ll turn out top notch going up in trip, but my head’s saying “he isn’t the best jumper”

But my point is, I’ve lost patience with Nicky now.

At least we know he’s horses will run at Newbury and Kempton’s annual away days, how fun!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lobos