• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

if Quilixios was mine i would be priming him up for a handicap at Cheltenham next season, gaining plenty racing experience along the way as the mark came down, plenty time the following season to take on better horses, however i don't think CP are that kind of owner, they would rather watch their horse in grade 1 races finishing 3rd or 4th, i reckon , and so just another 5yo ex juvenile not quite as good as we thought , a waste of a season
 
Aintree hurdle could be the race for him

But every chance he will struggle at the top level as a 5yo like many before him

Katchit was the last horse to go Triumph at 4 followed by Champion Hurdle at 5. Don't know of any other horse to go back to back as a 4 / 5 year old.
 
Katchit was the last horse to go Triumph at 4 followed by Champion Hurdle at 5. Don't know of any other horse to go back to back as a 4 / 5 year old.

Loads have run in a truimph and then CH the following season in general was prob the jist, just look at Goshen/Aspire Tower this year for example.
 
Always thought he might go Stayers. Gordon said last season that he wasn't your typical 4yo so he might not be your typical 5yo going for the Stayers.

I would be more confident of that if he was with Gordon still.

That nonsense of running him in the Boodles, after he thrashed the Grade 1 field at the DRF was very strange, just to keep him away from Zanahiyr!

Not sure that Henry targets the Stayers, at all, he usually loves a crack at the Champion though.

Put that together with 5yo’s recent record in both races, and 2M would seem the odds-on preferred option.

Probably the safest option, in readying him for his 6yo season the following year, without having put him through too many 3M slogs, too early in his career.
 
Last edited:
Always thought he might go Stayers. Gordon said last season that he wasn't your typical 4yo so he might not be your typical 5yo going for the Stayers.

I tend to agree Lobos. Elliott has always mentioned Quilixios as being a stayer, which tends to be the case with Triumph horses, and of course he wasn’t a novice last year, which is perhaps to what Elliott was referring. I think 25-1 for the Stayers Hurdle is quite generous. I think I’ll keep my powder dry until I know more but he’s one I’ll be keeping my eye on, for sure. I will add, having watched the triumph back a few times, to me the horse staying on was Zanahiyr not Quilixios.
 
Some lad on twitter who has recent Patrick Mullins comments on the following:

Appreciate It

https://twitter.com/tayz2017/status/...994951690?s=19

Ferny Hollow

https://twitter.com/tayz2017/status/...302830082?s=19

Kilcruit & Sir Gerhard

https://twitter.com/tayz2017/status/...313164801?s=19

Also has a comment from HDB on Quilixios:

https://twitter.com/tayz2017/status/...071775235?s=19

ALL the horses came back in after Galway and it’s a case of same old at this stage of the year. We’re just gradually getting them ready and no real big decisions have been made yet. It’s obviously coming up to a very exciting time of the season and like everyone else, we’re looking forward to it.

Last season was brilliant but we missed out on the Champion Chase again and it’s the one race we’d love to win. It’s a really hot division this year with Shishkin there but we’ve got at least two big bullets to fire.

Chacun Pour Soi is good. Dermot Keeling, who rides him out, is happy with what he’s done. I’d imagine he’ll take a similar path to last year with the ultimate goal of the Champion Chase. Hopefully this is the year because we’ve got Energumene as well.


It was unfortunate that he missed Cheltenham but it was just a small knock and he came back and showed in Punchestown what he’s made of and he’s hugely exciting. I imagine we’ll try and keep both him and Chacun Pour Soi apart as much as we can.

Monkfish was disappointing in Punchestown but we’re putting that down to the fact that he maybe had a long season because he wasn’t at his best at Cheltenham either. I’d imagine we’ll be looking at all the big staying chases for him.



Appreciate It is good. He was brilliant at Cheltenham but just wasn’t firing on all cylinders before Punchestown so we missed that. He’s back in and he looks fantastic. I don’t know with him – does he go chasing? With the look of him, he’s an out-and-out chaser, a point-to-point winner, but he’s obviously not slow. I don’t know which way he’ll go but I think wherever he goes, he could do anything.

It’s a bit like the Vautour situation with him, any maybe Yorkhill. We could have went either way with those horses after their novice hurdle season. This fella is a bigger and wider type than both of those horses, but I think you have to go back to Bula to find the last horse to win the Supreme and the Champion Hurdle the following year, which will be a gap of 51 years come March. He looks every inch a chaser but the way he won the Supreme you’d have to consider the Champion Hurdle but the stats actually say it’s difficult.

Quite similarly to last year we have two top class bumper horses to go jumping with – Kilcruit and Sir Gerhard. It just goes to show you though, this time last year we were thinking Appreciate It was going to be a Ballymore or Albert Bartlett horse, so you never know until you start running them. They’re two very different horses.

Kilcruit is a light-framed, skinny horse, Sir Gerhard is a typical point-to-pointer. There’s not much between them on form. I think Sir Gerhard probably didn’t perform in Punchestown, and I think a lot of the horses that left Gordon’s ran well in Cheltenham and disappointed in Punchestown – it was probably a hard thing to do. Quilixios and Envoi Allen disappointed as well.



There’s not much between them and I don’t really know what way we’d split them up yet. We’ll just have to see how they go through the season.

It might be more straightforward with Allaho. Two and a half miles seems to suit him, the way he jumps and travels. He was catching Chacun Pour Soi at the finish of the Champion Chase at Punchestown, but I imagine Allaho falls into the Min bracket, for races like the John Durkan, given we have Energumene and Chacun for two-mile races.

Allaho can drop back to two miles no doubt, but I imagine the Ryanair is his main race.

Al Boum Photo is good but it might not be the case of the same as usual for him this year. I think last year, because of Covid, we maybe didn’t get the exact same preparation that we normally would so it’s not impossible to think that on a different day, he could have won the Gold Cup.

But he might be getting to the end of his prime now whereas there’s a few around him getting smack bang into their prime. Willie might consider taking in some of the bigger prizes through the winter with him but nothing has been decided yet.

Ferny Hollow is fine. He was back in training at the end of the season but he wasn’t going to be ready for Punchestown. We just got him back up to speed and he went out then a couple of weeks after the other horses went out. He’s back in again now. It’s mad when you look at his form, Bob Olinger and Appreciate It are two hugely exciting horses and he’s beaten them both. I’m still not sure how I managed to get him beat in two bumpers!

He falls into the could-be-anything category again and you have the option of going for a Champion Hurdle route or going chasing. Willie will have to sit down and think about that. He does look like a chaser, as a former point-to-pointer, but again he has all options open.

Saldier was in the Ebor but Willie wasn’t happy with him with his last bit of work and decided not to run him. He’s been kept on the go since Galway and he’s won a Morgiana before, so I imagine he could well end up there but there are some good flat races for him as well. Going back to the flat seemed to relight his fire a bit.

He’s always had a lot of potential, he just had a couple of unfortunate injuries and just seemed to lose his way a little bit, but with his head back in front now he could maybe do what we’d hoped he could do earlier in his career.

IT was a good summer. May wasn’t great but it got really nice about mid-June and the horses all look well.

Plenty of ours go home for the summer but a lot stay with us too. Some horses could be back in training from early or mid-July and the real winter horses start to come back in at the start of August. The timing depends on what you are targeting with them.

Honeysuckle had a lovely summer with Peter Molony at Rathmore Stud in Co Limerick. She looks brilliant.

We’ve decided to keep her over hurdles and I’d say she will have a similar campaign to last season, starting with the Hatton’s Grace, skipping Christmas and then Leopardstown, Cheltenham and Punchestown in the spring.

Our Grand National winner Minella Times recovered well after Aintree but it was never the plan to run him again after that and he went back to the McManus family’s Martinstown Stud for the summer. He came back looking brilliant. He won the National off 146 and ended up on 162 in the end-of-season Anglo-Irish ratings, though he is rated 159 in Ireland. We haven’t discussed plans for him yet.



The Gold Cup winner Minella Indo missed Punchestown with a bruised foot. He stayed with us for the summer and he had a great few months. We’re aiming him at the Champion Chase in Down Royal in early November, so it’s possible he could have an early start.

Put The Kettle On also stayed here for the summer. She enjoyed her holiday and is in fine fettle. The plan is to run her in the PWC Champion Chase at Gowran Park on Saturday, October 2nd. Her owners, the Dermodys, are looking forward to seeing her run at their local track.

She has won all four of her starts at Cheltenham and will hopefully go back there for the Shloer Chase in November. After that we will take a look and see where we are.


Bob Olinger missed Punchestown after giving a cough but he has summered well and is looking great. He jumps well, so we’re going chasing with him. He’s done very little wrong in his career to-date but this is a new season and a new test for him.

A Plus Tard has always been a good horse – he beat Chacun Pour Soi over two miles at Leopardstown one day – but the step up in trip to three miles seemed to bring out improvement in him last season. He won at Leopardstown over Christmas and then finished second to Minella Indo at Cheltenham. The one thing with him is he is definitely better going left-handed. For that reason we are looking at the Betfair Chase in Haydock on November 20th with him.

Quilixios was very good in the Triumph Hurdle and I’d say Punchestown was just one run too many for him. He has grown and strengthened into a gorgeous horse. We haven’t any firm plans for him and while it hasn’t been discussed I’d imagine he will stay over hurdles.

After being pulled up at Punchestown, Envoi Allen had a chip removed from his near hind joint. He had a nice break, is back cantering and seems really good now.
 
Thank's for posting this Crolwey113 :encouragement: , I'd definiteley be interested in A plus Tard going for the Betfair chase .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Run4Home
Thank's for posting this Crolwey113 :encouragement: , I'd definiteley be interested in A plus Tard going for the Betfair chase .

If he gets a prep run I would be very interested

But he has always needed his first run of the season if they go straight there
 
Random but Betfair have restricted my sportsbook as of today. They have very kindly said I am still welcome to use their casino :neglected:
 
Random but Betfair have restricted my sportsbook as of today. They have very kindly said I am still welcome to use their casino :neglected:

Thats the scandal.

Restricted on Sports but keep your pockets open for Casino.

Hopefully the Gambling Commission will outlaw that practice and make them split out those websites and log ins.
 
Last edited:
Random but Betfair have restricted my sportsbook as of today. They have very kindly said I am still welcome to use their casino :neglected:

Same happened to me at weekend as well. I assumed it had related to me using my ?5 free bet to have a 'big' ?2.50 Ew win with justanotherbottle recently :glee: as I have been placing mostly antepost bets otherwise. So it's not like I've been on a winning streak.

But yeah, I can still throw as much money at random chance games at the casino......
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lbur4288
At the races reporting that Davy Russell is on the verge of returning from injury, coinciding with the ban of Gordon Elliott finishing.
 
How much longer do we reckon Davy wants? I'm 37 now and the day after cricket I regret having ever gotten into sport, let alone being 42 and smashing my verterbrae!
 
How much longer do we reckon Davy wants? I'm 37 now and the day after cricket I regret having ever gotten into sport, let alone being 42 and smashing my verterbrae!

I think he'd rather retire on the back of a few big race wins rather than an injury. Not that he needs to prove anything anything anyone.
 
BHA announce changes to UK handicapping system, full story on RP website…
 
BHA announce changes to UK handicapping system, full story on RP website…

One line stood out in that to me "more rigorous back handicapping" which concerns me as based on their track record that will see a horse beaten by a head one week will bolt up in a shit field next race and the poor sod who had previously beaten the rag will see another 10lbs, and the cycle begins again :biggrin-new:
 
See below for article, about time and the bit I've highlighted made me chuckle! A very cushty job that many would lob a limb off for and do with genuine passion, and yet they think they are doing us a favour by being "Proactive". It's your job and requires common sense and being adaptable, not relying on an archaic way of rating horses!



The BHA’s head of handicapping says his team will take a far more proactive approach in future after announcing changes to their methodology on Wednesday in the wake of the poor performance of British horses at the Cheltenham Festival.

Among changes outlined as part of the BHA’s Quality Jumps Review, older horses will receive bigger drops after being beaten and the approach to handicapping novice hurdlers will be reassessed.

Explaining the rationale behind the changes, Dominic Gardiner-Hill said: "There was an awful lot of talk about how not just the Graded races [at Cheltenham] but the handicaps went. Ireland won seven, Britain won two. We then had the Grand National, and personally I think there were other issues involved there, but it was another issue on top of what happened at Cheltenham.

"Why have we suddenly found ourselves in this position? I think we were lulled into a false sense of security – on the surface there were not a lot of alarm bells. If you go back to the three previous festivals, there were ten handicaps and on each occasion they were split five apiece.

"We were aware of the analysis that showed Irish-trained handicappers were doing slightly better overall, but you would imagine horses sent across from Ireland would be fit, healthy and in form and that they would fare a little better as a result."



Ireland won seven of the nine handicaps at the Cheltenham Festival, including Mrs Milner in the Pertemps Final
Pool



BHA handicapping analysis had traditionally centred on the median rating of all horses under a certain code, and Gardiner-Hill said: "We were keeping an eye on the median. As long as that was stable, we were thinking things were okay. On top of that, we were still producing competitive handicaps day in, day out."

What focus on median ratings had missed, as shown by analysis from economist Kevin Barrins which was published in the Racing Post in April, was the overall distribution of runners. Barrins pointed out that the relative shape of British and Irish distributions was different, putting too many British-trained hurdlers in the crucial range where the biggest handicaps are fought.

The BHA's analysis shows that the modal value – the single rating that is held by the largest number of horses – had increased by around 10lb over hurdles between 2018 and 2021 compared with ten years earlier. Over fences, it was more than 20lb. The overall distributions show a rightward shift over the period that would be consistent with handicap slippage.









Gardiner-Hill accepted this, but pointed out: "My view is that we're the only handicapping jurisdiction in the world, with the possible exception of Hong Kong, that would undergo this sort of analysis on our own file."

Asked how it had happened over time, he said: "I think you need to go back to before Phil Smith became head of handicapping. Then it was the case that horses often went up 2-3lb for winning and you got horses running up sequences of six, eight wins on the trot. Phil changed our methodology, which was fairer to more horses as it made these sequences harder, but not impossible.

"That got us into a position we wanted to be in, but then we carried on and probably went a bit too far. Now we're adjusting our methodology again. It's nothing seismic, but we need to be sure that as younger horses improve into the area in which we found the issue [hurdlers rated around 110 to 145] a similar number of exposed older horses are dropping out."



Dominic Gardiner-Hill: "We're the only handicapping jurisdiction in the world, with the possible exception of Hong Kong, that would undergo this sort of analysis on our own file"
Edward Whitaker



On novice hurdlers, Gardiner-Hill added: "I do think, and the analysis will tell you, that there are certain horses in the novice hurdle division that should be rated a little lower to make them competitive earlier."

On the three approaches considered by the BHA review, Gardiner-Hill revealed an algorithmic reassessment of around 4,000 horses was given a dry run and may help shape changes to the system in the coming months.

"We ran the algorithm, and we noted the changes it would have made," he explained. "We're using that to give us an indication of the sort of adjustments we will need to make in order to get where we want to be. It might be that horses that would have previously gone down 1lb or 2lb now go down 2lb or 3lb."

The algorithmic approach was ultimately rejected because, according to Gardiner-Hill: "Had we done that, I couldn't have told you why certain horses' marks had been altered. I think connections would much rather ring us up and be given a pounds-and-ounces justification rather than have their horses' marks left entirely to an algorithm. The trainers I've spoken to about these changes have largely been very supportive – and why wouldn't they be?"

Gardiner-Hill also pledged to make sure the slippage of recent years does not happen again.

"We'll be looking at the file on at least a monthly basis. The one thing we can't do is redress the balance and just say: 'That's it, guys; we've done it.' We have got to keep the pressure on and make sure it doesn't happen again.

"It's a case of lessons learned; we've got to make use of the data that we know our analysts can now produce. I've got so much more confidence now in the analysis we are using.

"I will hold my hands up. Perhaps we should have done this sort of in-depth analysis earlier. But we're doing something about it now, we're being proactive and we will get it done by January 1."


Reiterating the overall aims of the review, he said: "We want everyone to go to the races thinking they've got a chance of winning. If that means taking the occasional knock, and being told that you haven't done one or two things quite as well as you could have then that's life. Learn from it and make things better."

He added: "Our measures of success will be primarily data-driven; this is entirely separate to the jumps review as it's all in-house and has very few external stakeholders.

"But you have to consider Cheltenham. It could be that we're sitting here on March 20 next year and the Irish have won seven of the nine handicaps again. If that happens, we may well have another look. But even if they do, I don't want anyone to be able to say to us: you lazy buggers, you got battered last year, you swept it under the carpet and did nothing."
 
Not sure where to put this, but this was on Twitter this morning....

RubyTuesday
@Ruby_Tuesday59
Robcour News
Aspire Tower stays hurdling, aim is FF at Newcastle
Magic Daze novice chasing
Chris Dream apparently being aimed at the Hennessy
Gentleman Joe recruited from the Flat could be one for Triumph, has form behind Yibir & Lone Eagle on last run at Goodwood.