I know I keep beating the same drum but anyone who fancies Monkfish to win the Gold Cup just can't ignore Elimay. Monkfish rated 163 and Elimay rated 155. Take into account the 7lb Mares allowance and there's 1lb between them. She looks like she'll stay all day long so the step up will suit. We know she handles Cheltenham and the big occasion, she jumps for fun and she's as game as they come. 6/1 v 40/1. No more comments your honour.
I have a few of issues with this. It's easy to compare ratings against prices and come up with a bet, but it's rarely that simple.
Firstly, course form, Monkfish is 2 from 2 at Cheltenham, Elimay is 0 from 2, whichever way you want to spin it, i.e. the Colreevy form line which I'll come to later.
Secondly, distance, Monkfish has not just won twice at the course, but also both times being over 3m, which leaves him with a lot less to prove than Elimay, who won a weak Mares Chase at Fairyhouse over 2m 5f, the furthest she has run to date.
Thirdly, there is nothing to suggest, in Elimays breeding, that she'll get the Gold Cup trip.
Gave Allaho a fright who murdered them in Ryanair. Easily beat Mount Ida who won at the fez from an impossible position. Smashed Black Tears who won the Mares Hurdle and just got pipped by Colreevy who beat Monkfish out of sight. Just an incredible list.
Form lines, on the Colreevy one, first off Monkfish had a fairly long and tough season prior to that run, and secondly Colreevy's breeding suggested she'd be better suited to a longer trip anyway, so the fact she outbattled Elimay at Cheltenham over shorter is more a nod to how game and good Colreevy is than to how good Elimay is, IMO. On the Mount Ida form line, again, her breeding definitely suggests she'll be better suited over further, and duly obliged at the festival over 3m 2f, but she was hammered by Colreevy the race before that win over 2m 4f, yet only just over 2 lengths down from Elimay at Fairyhouse over an almost identical inadequate trip.
I rarely knock a 40/1 poke, but Elimay has a fair amount of questions to answer for me before I even consider her a Gold Cup runner, let alone the prospect of being competitive in one.