• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

RSA Chase 2020

On average 2-3 festival winners are PU LTO. The fact CT put him in the race was a positive in itself. He had no right to be turning in as close as he was after that many jumping errors. Not ideal but certainly not without an EW chance

handicaps or group 1s?
 
I stand corrected GS. I didn’t realise Santini was so lightly raced over fences, I forgot he spent a few months injured last season.

Mad how positive some on here are about slate houses run on Saturday! I thought it was a very poor round of jumping,never ever looked like getting into the race at all,said it before but if Champ would have put this performance in,I’d bet the positive spin put on this would have been the exact opposite
 
Mad how positive some on here are about slate houses run on Saturday! I thought it was a very poor round of jumping,never ever looked like getting into the race at all,said it before but if Champ would have put this performance in,I’d bet the positive spin put on this would have been the exact opposite

Couldn’t agree more with this, people crabbing carefully selected for winning but finding a way to be positive about a shocking run from Slate House.
 
Mad how positive some on here are about slate houses run on Saturday! I thought it was a very poor round of jumping,never ever looked like getting into the race at all,said it before but if Champ would have put this performance in,I’d bet the positive spin put on this would have been the exact opposite

Agree 100% Slate House was shocking - period. Can't jump and a trip too far imo
 
Mad how positive some on here are about slate houses run on Saturday! I thought it was a very poor round of jumping,never ever looked like getting into the race at all,said it before but if Champ would have put this performance in,I’d bet the positive spin put on this would have been the exact opposite

Couldn’t agree more with this, people crabbing carefully selected for winning but finding a way to be positive about a shocking run from Slate House.

Sorry chaps,

Where are the posts with all the positives for Slate House?



If you read properly the things people are saying, they're taking into account his overall profile and saying he might be value now.


The comparisons to what Champ would have done are stupid. I can absolutely assure you, if they pushed Champ out to 16/1 everybody would be able to find positives....... because we're looking for value.



We want to see why a horse might be over priced.



Carefully Selected did win, but he's still a very short price..... if they pushed him out to 16/1, would he be a better bet? Absolutely!
 
Agree 100% Slate House was shocking - period. Can't jump and a trip too far imo

Grade 1 winner, over 3 miles.






I'm leaving this forum for the night... :rolleyes:

I'll go round in circles debating a point that isn't even there.
 
Sorry chaps,

Where are the posts with all the positives for Slate House?



If you read properly the things people are saying, they're taking into account his overall profile and saying he might be value now.


The comparisons to what Champ would have done are stupid. I can absolutely assure you, if they pushed Champ out to 16/1 everybody would be able to find positives....... because we're looking for value.



We want to see why a horse might be over priced.



Carefully Selected did win, but he's still a very short price..... if they pushed him out to 16/1, would he be a better bet? Absolutely!

Amen. Your response was more diplomatic than mine :)
 
Amen. Your response was more diplomatic than mine :)

Slate House has definitely got an engine and has a lot of ability.
They appear to want to hold him up though.
He does make mistakes and this often means he stays at or near the back.
But he has travelled back into races where he had no right too. The handicap where he fell at the second last was the best example.
He'll need to jump a good round in the RSA, but if he does and the run Saturday hasn't affected him too much, he'll have a few of the knockers worried coming to the second last.

I've not backed him myself at any point.
But I might do at some stage, depending on lots of other things. Mainly prices as he's not one I'd rule out. Although the number of runs he's had is a concern. But could also be to his advantage too.

He's had 5 runs and will probably get a break now until March

Blaklion
Presenting Percy
Bostons Angel
Lord Windermere

All ran 5 times too, although these ran there last races in mid feb mainly.
 
Grade 1 winner, over 3 miles.






Just my opinion but I reckon he needs a fast run 2 and a half against top class horses. Just think his best chance would be outstaying the speedier types in that scenario. Whatever he does he needs to brush up his jumping - still too many errors. I liked the way he went through the BetVictor before crashing out when looking like sluicing up. For my money 2 and a half around Cheltenham saw him at his best. Would I back him for the Marsh? No. But gun to head would prefer him in that compared to the RSA.
 
I feel Slate House is just short of top class. While he won a Grade 1 at Christmas, Grade 1s at Cheltenham are at a different level. I could see Champ, Minella Indo, Allaho or Battleoverdoyen becoming Gold Cup horses next year but can't imagine Slate House reaching that level.
 
My biggest issue with Slate House is his jumping is usually sticky/slow early on. I backed him earlier in the season for the JLT but I don't think I'd really fancy him for any race at Cheltenham as I think he'll be too far behind and be playing catch up all race. The exception would have been the NH Chase and he isn't entered for that.
 
I feel Slate House is just short of top class. While he won a Grade 1 at Christmas, Grade 1s at Cheltenham are at a different level. I could see Champ, Minella Indo, Allaho or Battleoverdoyen becoming Gold Cup horses next year but can't imagine Slate House reaching that level.

Best summary i reckon
 
What noises? Market seems to suggest your pocket is right.

Apologies, I musnt have heard the noise, but as mentioned in JLT thread Allaho 4/1 fav with sky! What about Faugheen then? Worth a punt in RSA? Or few dreams still alive in 4 miler...
 
I feel Slate House is just short of top class. While he won a Grade 1 at Christmas, Grade 1s at Cheltenham are at a different level. I could see Champ, Minella Indo, Allaho or Battleoverdoyen becoming Gold Cup horses next year but can't imagine Slate House reaching that level.

Slate House for me doesn’t dine at top table , agree with you
 
I feel Slate House is just short of top class. While he won a Grade 1 at Christmas, Grade 1s at Cheltenham are at a different level. I could see Champ, Minella Indo, Allaho or Battleoverdoyen becoming Gold Cup horses next year but can't imagine Slate House reaching that level.

I think that's a fair assessment and in the fullness of time I would expect Champ, Minella Indo and Battleoverdoyen to go on to bigger and better things, but it goes back to price, especially in a race where the battle hardened fair well. Was Blaklion top class? Was O'Faolains Boy top class? Was Trabolgan top class? There's lots of horses that win this without being top class, and there are plenty of horses left in behind them that have gone off very short having been just as well fancied.

In the context of this race experience matters, and in your quest for value you have Champ @ 3/1 who has been to Cheltenham once over fences and fallen. Minella Indo is 5/1 having had 2 starts over fences and I wasn't overly impressed with his last run. Battleoverdoyen is 13/2 and has only ever lost at Cheltenham. Allaho looks to be Marsh bound. Then you have Slate House @ 16/1. Were it not for his unfortunate tip up in the BetVictor he'd be 2/3 at Cheltenham and go into this with a Grade 1 over 3 miles on his CV. That's invaluable experience and IMO the value EW bet in the race at this time.
 
From a betting perspective I’ve covered Slate House but would be surprised if there at the business end

Sam Brown 20/1 NRNB to me of more interest
 
Which bookmaker can you get 20/1 nrnb with? I may be interested at those odds but only with nrnb. I can only see 12/1 nrnb which doesnt interest me as he may not come here and if he does 12/1 is far too short.

Was Skybet


Best now 16/1 with 365 Cash out
 
Last edited:
Black Op is the forgotten horse in this race I feel.
Beaten 1 3/4 lengths by Champ and 1 3/4 lengtgs by Slate House.
The defeat to Champ he made a mistake at the last amd then was hampered yet he still stayed on but just didnt have the pace of Champ. That was over 2m 4f on a flat track and he could reverse that form in the RSA over a longer trip and with the uphill finish.
He also ran well behind Slate House where kemptons sharp track probably went against him. I would confidently expect him to reverse that form at Cheltenham.

His only previous run at the course was when 2nd at the 2018 festival to the 'unbeatable'(at the time) Samcro. Next destination 5 lengths further back in 3rd.

I think Black Ops has a strong chance of winning the RSA and he is over priced.

So Slate House 'wont be involved in the finish of any race in March' but Black Op has a strong chance of winning the RSA :rolleyes:

At very similar prices (16's v 20's) I'd side with Slate House. I've just watched the Grade 1 back and there was nothing unlucky about it. Black Op had every chance to win his race and were it not for a poor jump at the last Slate House would have won going away.

But Slate House has no chance of placing, the other has a strong chance of winning. Sound logic