• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

RSA Chase 2020

You appear to not want to recognise that Slate House is clearly an early season horse oct/nov/dec whos season target was the betvictor handicap.
Last season can be forgotten for Slate House as he had issues and 2 wind ops. The season before however again he won in october and november (his time of year). In november he beat Summerville Boy over 2m 1/2f at Cheltenham. By the festival in March (no longer his time of year) he got destroyed by Tom Georges Summerville Bo Slate House fell at the last but he was a very well beat 7th.

Why did Slate House go from brushing Summerville Boy aside to getting battered by him at the festival? The answers simple and its because he is an early season horse. Using your apparent 'sound logic' this couldnt have happened.

I never claimed Black Ops was unlucky at Kempton. He was having his 3rd chase start against a horse in Slate House who was having his 7th chase start.

We know that Slate House is a better horse early season and the sharp track was against Black Ops. It seems perfectly reasonable to expect Black Ops to reverse that form in the month of March at a track where the only horse to have beaten him was the god like(at that moment in time) Samcro.

Its perfectly sound logic. The Tizzards know full well Slate House is an early season horse hence why his season target was The Betvictor gold cup. They know he wont be competitive in March They may still run him as surely this horses target is now the Ladbrokes Trophy in November. A few more unplaced runs will help his handicap mark drop for the start of next season when the horse is at his best in November.

The point of my post wasn’t to knock your thoughts re Black Op RG, it was to highlight that you are making definitive statements that are just personal opinions. 'Slate House is clearly an early season horse’ - that's your opinion. Some might argue that deducing this about an 8 year old that's raced 4 times in March/April/May having been injured and had wind issue is premature.

Anyway, lets get back to talking about horses that are likely to win an RSA (and for the record I don't think Slate House or Black Op fall under the banner of likely) :)
 
Can you explain your logic of backing a horse for the RSA that you consider an unlikely winner?

To my mind that doesnt make any sense whatsover.


Also it clearly isnt just my opinion that Slate House is an early season horse. The form book backs it up and the fact that his trainer had an early season race as this horses season target with no mention of any festival plans backs up my opinion that he is an early season horse.

We have already in fact seen that Slate House has already gone backwards due to his non show last saturday. He will only get worse from here on in. This further backs up the arguement he is an early season horse as he appears to have already peaked earlier in the season.

I think he's an each way value play.

Its OK Ruby Grolsch, the beauty of this forum is we can agree to disagree. You have your view re Slate House, I have mine.

There are more likely winners we can discuss. For example, what do you think of Champ's chances?
 
I think that Champ will struggle in this race due to his jumping. If he puts in a perfect round of jumping then he would have a chance but thats unlikely to happen and his jumping will become more exposed than ever at grade 1 level at the festival.

I would also expect Black Op to reverse form here as it was only champs turn of foot that beat him. With the extra 4 1/2 f and an uphill finish this will negate Champs turn of foot and play into Black Ops hands. I dont see how Black Ops is over 5 times the price of Champ here.

If you want to read about 20 pages on the subject then feel free to go back through this thread, along with a few other theories why he wont win that are not so obvious!! lol
 
The Kauto Star novice chase has a strong recent history of the winner turning out to be not as good as the horses he beat.

La Bague Au roi beat Topofthegame and Santini in the race. Both Topofthegame and Santini are clearly superior horses to La Bague Au Roi.

Black Corton beat Elegant Escape in the kauto star but that form was reversed in the RSA that season.

Teafortwo beat Native River in the Kauto Star. when they met at the festival Native River comfortably reversed taht form.

Grands Crus beat Bobs Worth comfortably in the Kauto. A few months later Bobs Worth comfortably reversed that form at the festival.

What does this logic you speak of make of the above results?

History shows its better to be placed in the Kauto star than it is to win it.

You've mentioned the phrase "early season horse" 7 times in two posts, Ruby good work. I think we get the point you don't need to keep saying it :highly_amused:
 
If you want to read about 20 pages on the subject then feel free to go back through this thread, along with a few other theories why he wont win that are not so obvious!! lol

You've mentioned the phrase "early season horse" 7 times in two posts, Ruby good work. I think we get the point you don't need to keep saying it :highly_amused:

You not figured it out yet chaps?
 
If Black Op wins here I’m giving up the game. I mean ...... really !!!??? This race has always been good for throwing up genuine Gold Cup contenders. Does anyone really think Black Op is a future gold cup winner ??? The marsh I’d give him a squeak at best and only because the race looks poor on paper. To win this RSA ???? More chance of Twiston Davies admitting Bristol ain’t good enough to win a gold cup !!!!
 
Nobody fancy danny whizzbang here..all over him..think he being massively overlooked..decent run at kempton over xmas in same race as topofthegame placed in last yr before goin on to win rsa for nicholls also..defo the e/w one for me..
 
Nobody fancy danny whizzbang here..all over him..think he being massively overlooked..decent run at kempton over xmas in same race as topofthegame placed in last yr before goin on to win rsa for nicholls also..defo the e/w one for me..

He was my dark horse in the thread. I like him a lot. Just not convinced he will turn up here but would love it if he did.
 
Ive come down to these four who I expect to fight out the finish , Champ , Battleoverdoyen , Minello Indo and Allaho. Jumping well at pace the key though , going to be interesting on how it pans out.Good luck with your choices.
 
Do we still think Allaho goes here not Marsh? Will it depend on Faugheen’s destination?
 
Ive come down to these four who I expect to fight out the finish , Champ , Battleoverdoyen , Minello Indo and Allaho. Jumping well at pace the key though , going to be interesting on how it pans out.Good luck with your choices.

I'd be happy with that scenario.
On decent ground, I would side with Champ IF he can jump OK (no need to discuss this at length again though... :encouragement:)
Anything softer and stamina will come more into play for the likes of Minella Indo.
Happy to have any one of those win!
 
This is a 2 horse race between the 2 horses placed 2nd and 3rd in the Kauto Star chase.

DANNY WHIZZBANG ew 50/1
BLACK OP ew 20/1

I surely cannot lose here.

Ok ...... your going to have to show your workings as to how you’ve come to this conclusion.
 
I apready have I tipped him up perhaps under Prince Harry id ir perhaps under a different one. Only a few pages back.

Danny Whizzbang is tipped back in the thread before his chase debut.

Feel free to read.

Ruby Grolsch not Prince Harry.

My time is limited. Charlie and Jack are currently desperately emailing the moderators about me. Bless them.

That confirms it.
You are in fact an Extra Terrestrial.

A Mogwai ??

A fictitious alien creature that multiplies into different forms when threatened.
Seen in the film Gremlins, which is perfectly Apt.
 
That confirms it.
You are in fact an Extra Terrestrial.

A Mogwai ??

A fictitious alien creature that multiplies into different forms when threatened.
Seen in the film Gremlins, which is perfectly Apt.

:highly_amused::highly_amused:
 
Thank you sir.

A brand new day a brand new id. I post whenever I want. FACT.

If I deserved to be banned then I would accept it. Being banned for having the opinion Willie Mullins will have his worst ever festival. I simply dont respect.

Eyup ET :)
 
Thank you sir.

A brand new day a brand new id. I post whenever I want. FACT.

If I deserved to be banned then I would accept it. Being banned for having the opinion Willie Mullins will have his worst ever festival. I simply dont respect.

Controversial! WM and GE will spank the English again this year "IMO" With HDB picking up 3 winners of course!

As for Danny WhizzBang, how confident are you he comes here?
 
Sigh ....

Imagine believing you were banned for having an opinion?


You can create as many as you like, it's quick to ban and delete and if you do sneak any accounts through, you'd have to be completely different and probably wouldn't annoy people so much?


I promise I'll lift the ban the ET account if EE wins the Gold Cup though.
 
Sigh ....

Imagine believing you were banned for having an opinion?


You can create as many as you like, it's quick to ban and delete and if you do sneak any accounts through, you'd have to be completely different and probably wouldn't annoy people so much?


I promise I'll lift the ban the ET account if EE wins the Gold Cup though.

I think we’re safe
 
Does this mean you don’t think Elegant Escape is the new messiah or you believe Champ is the new God to follow :highly_amused:
Welcome back ET/Prince Harry/Champ....I do agree with you that this maybe Mullins worst festival for a few years but he will get a few winners and lots of places, just not the numbers we’ve expected. I think a few outside the top 4 will win a few like Skelton, HDB, Murphy and Hobbs to balance it out.