• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

RSA Chase 2020

I don't understand how many can overlook Battleoverdoyen for this. Undefeated nag, The concern is he didn't travel well last year the bigger concern is he didn't enjoy the course! But as a chaser he looks solid right now I'm hoping he jumps them silly (he'll Defo jump the favourite silly anyway!)
 
How can you arrive at that Lobos after those two chase runs. Hes going to lack experience, the only half decent horse hes faced is Laurina and her level of form is open to massive scrutiny at the moment. Hes proved very little over fences. If Champ had just beaten that lot by that distance you wouldnt of had him for one second? What are you seeing that makes you think hes the winner? Dont take this the wrong way, Im genuinely interested? Without stating the obvious there are some pretty smart chasers hes going up against. People seem very keen on giving this horse a free pass for average runs in the belief it will be alright on the big day. If he was having another run against better company I could see it much more, but hes going there after those two chases and I just dont get it.

He's been brought along nicely so far and it's clear they have left plenty to work on. He'll be spot in and ready to do the business in March as he was last year. He jumps, he stays, he has class and good hurdles form, he's honest, he keeps out of trouble, he can battle, he's won at the festival so won't be fazed by the noise/hustle/bustle, he'll go on any ground, he has a great jockey and has one target. Apart from that I don't know why I like him.
 
He's been brought along nicely so far and it's clear they have left plenty to work on. He'll be spot in and ready to do the business in March as he was last year. He jumps, he stays, he has class and good hurdles form, he's honest, he keeps out of trouble, he can battle, he's won at the festival so won't be fazed by the noise/hustle/bustle, he'll go on any ground, he has a great jockey and has one target. Apart from that I don't know why I like him.

I keep watching the Albert Bartlett back from last season and he was by far the best horse in that race. He has all the attributes to be a top horse (listed by Lobos) but his two chase runs have left me doubting myself. Like most, I'm hoping there was plenty to work on and the required improvement will come in the spring.
 
He's been brought along nicely so far and it's clear they have left plenty to work on. He'll be spot in and ready to do the business in March as he was last year. He jumps, he stays, he has class and good hurdles form, he's honest, he keeps out of trouble, he can battle, he's won at the festival so won't be fazed by the noise/hustle/bustle, he'll go on any ground, he has a great jockey and has one target. Apart from that I don't know why I like him.

Wish you luck. Im amazed people are prepared to give him a free pass in the hope that he will be ok on the day, that run was about 12 lbs below what would be needed in an average RSA. I cant have him at all personally on those two runs they were very average and thats being kind. If Champ jumps round Minella Indo wont get near him:)
 
Wish you luck. Im amazed people are prepared to give him a free pass in the hope that he will be ok on the day, that run was about 12 lbs below what would be needed in an average RSA. I cant have him at all personally on those two runs they were very average and thats being kind. If Champ jumps round Minella Indo wont get near him:)

IF Champ jumps round ?

That’s the question, superb engine ,but IF Champ was trained and owned / supported / promoted by lesser known personalities and on form alone should he be as short as he is ? I’m repeating myself ( again :) )and have posted similar previously , just my opinion

Backed at 10’s but wouldn’t at today’s / race day prices .

Could easily with a good jumping display win well and I know that is stating the obvious :highly_amused:
 
I don't understand how many can overlook Battleoverdoyen for this. Undefeated nag, The concern is he didn't travel well last year the bigger concern is he didn't enjoy the course! But as a chaser he looks solid right now I'm hoping he jumps them silly (he'll Defo jump the favourite silly anyway!)

Best jumper at the top of the market NQAT
 
I’d have battleoverdoyen, slate house, Faugheen and champ way ahead of minella indo
 
I’d have battleoverdoyen, slate house, Faugheen and champ way ahead of minella indo

Couldn’t agree more Billy. I don’t think last year’s AB form is really that good, nothing has really franked it. MI is incredibly short IMO for what he has achieved, particularly over fences. I like BOD and have covered at big prices thanks to Charlie, Faugheen will go to The Marsh and Slate House can’t win because he won the Kauto Star :highly_amused: Champ just wins this.
 
I’d have battleoverdoyen, slate house, Faugheen and champ way ahead of minella indo
Completely agree on this. The AB form of last year is worth nothing of substance and the defeat to Laurina albeit over an inadequate trip would have to be a concern. HDB in great form this year but I simply can’t have Minella Indo in this
 
Completely agree on this. The AB form of last year is worth nothing of substance and the defeat to Laurina albeit over an inadequate trip would have to be a concern. HDB in great form this year but I simply can’t have Minella Indo in this

He did it nicely at Punchestown as well though - is there such a thing as a poor grade 1?
He's definitely got the class to go right to the top (imo) but I do think he's a couple of points shorter than he should be on his runs this season.
 
He did it nicely at Punchestown as well though - is there such a thing as a poor grade 1?
He's definitely got the class to go right to the top (imo) but I do think he's a couple of points shorter than he should be on his runs this season.

Essentially he just beat the same horses again at Punch, with the exception of Carefully Selected, who didn’t have the best of preps last year. Just don’t think the overall form is as good as it appeared at the time.
 
I think Pym is flying under the radar for many people. Won at Cheltenham will stay the trip no problem (won over 3m 1f), wins his prep for this will be a massive player.

Can’t have champ md at the prices now
 
I’d have battleoverdoyen, slate house, Faugheen and champ way ahead of minella indo

Take Faugheen out of that (likely goes JLT) and you have my 4 against the field at tidy prices. Any one will do but MI is my idea of the winner. Regarding him needing to improve on his 2 chase runs.......he will, the RSA is not won in December/January. Slowly, slowly, catchy monkey.
 
I’d have battleoverdoyen, slate house, Faugheen and champ way ahead of minella indo

This really does confuse me, way ahead ?? I’d love to hear why ?
All of the horses above apart from Faugheen have literally beat nothing in they’re whole racing life. Remember one thing ....... minella indo has been there and done it at the festival and done it very impressively. Slate house is a handicapper at best so to think he can step up to this race is unthinkable for me.

I see a lot of negative comments regarding Minella’s latest performance........ jumped fine to my eye and will improve massively for the run. Take a look at his route to Cheltenham last year and that should ease any concerns. Don’t want to keep digging Champ out but seriously.... overrated would be an understatement.

For me Minella Indo is the horse to beat and in all honesty I can’t see any other winner of the race.
 
This really does confuse me, way ahead ?? I’d love to hear why ?
All of the horses above apart from Faugheen have literally beat nothing in they’re whole racing life. Remember one thing ....... minella indo has been there and done it at the festival and done it very impressively. Slate house is a handicapper at best so to think he can step up to this race is unthinkable for me.

.


Bit strong to say it's unthinkable that a handicapper (Who is actually a Grade 1 winner?!) can't step up?


He has Grade 1 Chase form, that's arguably better than Grade 1 Hurdle form for a Grade 1 RSA Chase, no?



UNTHINKABLE.
 
I see a lot of negative comments regarding Minella’s latest performance........ jumped fine to my eye and will improve massively for the run. Take a look at his route to Cheltenham last year and that should ease any concerns. Don’t want to keep digging Champ out but seriously.... overrated would be an understatement.

For me Minella Indo is the horse to beat and in all honesty I can’t see any other winner of the race.

Part 2

Also too strong.

You can't see any other winner?

Faugheen, Champ, Slate House and Battleoverdoyen all literally have better Chase form.


You're very much hoping Minella Indo replicates last seasons improvement, that's hardly something you can guarantee?



Also, "jumped fine" is what most people have said, that's hardly a ringing endorsement is it, for a horse you cannot see beaten?!
 
Part of the problem is the modern training methods keep horses in their boxes for too long, you get to mid Jan and novices have only been out once so we have little to go by.
In years gone by it used to be that novices, especially chasers, were sent out 3/4 times pre March so they get to Cheltenham with plenty of experience, not the way these days....