• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

No there is no precedent in Irish Racing for it + they cannot do it.
Also, BHA say they are not able to suspend him, they are though, free to block entries + dec's (basically the same to my eye lol).

Worth listening to Nick Luck's podcast.


....ah, so a glimmer of hope for the Festival. The BHA could suspend any new entries, given the Cheltenham entries are already in.
 
....ah, so a glimmer of hope for the Festival. The BHA could suspend any new entries, given the Cheltenham entries are already in.

I believe they can suspend declarations from that trainer as well. Would be incredibly harsh on the owners and I envisage there could be law suits from that as someone else mentioned
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eggs
So they can't suspend the guy who was in the picture but they can ban owners horses who haven't done anything wrong? Sounds unlikely to me, despite what they 'can do'.

Look, it was Lydia Hislop on his podcast relaying what was told to her by BHA. Have a listen. :tongue-new: No power to suspend, but power to refuse entries or declarations, "but that is a very high bar legally from them. That's how she understands it from their response to her questioning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ComplyOrDie
I believe they can suspend declarations from that trainer as well. Would be incredibly harsh on the owners and I envisage there could be law suits from that as someone else mentioned

They can, i said that in the original post as did GS...
 
BHA would need to have deep pockets if they took that route
 
If either authority bans him prior to a hearing and he's then found not guilty, they are up the creek without a rowing implement. It's not like an industrial tribunal where you can suspend someone on full pay. He will have to keep a low profile for some time but it's a high risk policy to take any action beyond not allowing him entry to racecourses.

The injured party here is Gigginstown and they seem content to move on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Craigy14 and ToniC
Any ban & appeal (look at Burns, still trained a DRF winner under appeal) means he’ll technically still be able to have runners at the festival. Think the main question here is all about owners brand reputation. Let’s use Cheveley Park as the best example. They have 4 high profile entries including the most talked about horse in training with him. They’re in the NH game for the love, not money. They run one of the biggest breeding operations in the world. If I was working in PR at that company, none of those would be running due to brand reputation - because even if they are moved, story by association / link is still negative PR. That’s how big corporates work. I personally do not think we’ll see Envoi Allen, Sir G, Ballyadam or Quilixios at the festival. Really hope I’m wrong - fear branding & business will come over fun & passion though

Tony Calvin just made similar point to what I was trying to get across on Weighed In podcast - even if the individuals want to stand by them (and appreciate Gigginstown statement), the brand effect could just be irreparable....

Whatever your personal view on this today, it’s just completely ruined this years festival build up for me...
 
If either authority bans him prior to a hearing and he's then found not guilty, they are up the creek without a rowing implement. It's not like an industrial tribunal where you can suspend someone on full pay. He will have to keep a low profile for some time but it's a high risk policy to take any action beyond not allowing him entry to racecourses.

The injured party here is Gigginstown and they seem content to move on.

Archie, the injured party is anyone who works or cares about racing. He’s brought the sport into disrepute.

There’s nothing to be found not guilty of. He sat on a dead horse without any remorse on display. Even if his explanation is true (which I don’t believe at all), absent mindedly sitting on a dead horse to take a phone call isn’t much better than jokingly posing for it. Both display a callous and careless approach to a horse’s live and neither reflect the care so many others have for horses in their care. Why even take the damn call in the first place at that moment of gravity. Horses die, we all know that. But you have to treat the situation as it deserves. Perhaps this is representative of his approach to animal welfare in general? What evidence is there to say it isn’t. Actions and words and all that.

He did it and admitted it. He has to be suspended and licence revoked immediately (if nothing else but to show the sport cares about the welfare of its animals) and then an investigation can be held. If there are found to be mitigating circumstances, his punishment will be light and licence reinstated. There are zero legal risks to that approach. As part of having a licence he will have signed up to standards of conduct, amongst other things, that place him at the behest of the IHRB. He operates under the IHRB; their duty is to protect the sport and they have the authority to do suspend him. He’d have nothing to fall back on legally.
 
People laugh at funerals do they not care?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brital
The horse is dead. The chatter about horse welfare is over-reactionary nonsense.

I get what you're saying, but you don't throw respect and care out of the window just cos something is no longer alive.
And it throws into serious doubt how the individual treats things that are alive.

If I saw a teenager kicking a dead cat along the road, I wouldn't just turn a blind eye cos it's already dead.
I'd hit the little fucker on the back of the head with a large Tablespoon.
Then make him dig a hole to bury it in. (with the same tablespoon)
 
Last edited:
Archie, the injured party is anyone who works or cares about racing. He’s brought the sport into disrepute.

I think some perspective is needed here, yes we're all disappointed by what we've seen but I really don't see this as a 'trophy' photo celebrating the death of a racehorse, it is without doubt poor judgement and also without doubt incredible stupidity that he allowed someone, and you would think this has to be a staff member, to take the photo and retain it.
Every sport is brought into disripute multiple times a season, sometimes multiple times a day, countless drug cheats in athletics, numerous drug/drink/driving and assault cases in NFL, match fixing in tennis, spot fixing in cricket as well as bottle tops, dirt and sandpaper to affect the ball, the list is endless, bribery to win hosting rights to tournaments, and I've not even mentioned the hundreds of cheats in football to dive their way around a field and do their level best to mislead refs and get opponents sent off.
It was horrible to see but, and I'm in no way defending Elliott, there are a number of brutal/primitive processes adopted when managing large/heavy animals in yards, farms and zoos that might surprise a few people, click on the 'take photo' button at the right time and you can easily make a judgement that isn't right.
Why Elliott chose to sit on a dead horse is beyond me, it's tactless and highly stupid of course but unlikely to be career ending...
 
People laugh at funerals do they not care?

I agree with this.
Him smiling does not matter, it just looks bad.
It would be completely natural and actually professional for him to have gained a hard nosed practical reaction to the death of horses.
If he was broken into pieces every time then he would be in the wrong job.

When I put my dog down the other night, I didn't expect the VET to be in floods of tears, only myself.
Which is why I bottled it and let the Mrs go on her own.
I did offer, but she was braver than me.
A good wife indeed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf
I get what you're saying, but you don't throw respect and care out of the window just cos something is no longer alive.
And it throws into serious doubt how the individual treats things that are alive.

If I saw a teenager kicking a dead cat along the road, I wouldn't just turn a blind eye cos it's already dead.
I'd hit the little fucker on the back of the head with a large Tablespoon.
Then make him dig a hole to bury it in.

I agree with all that.

He’s been disrespectful, he’s been distasteful, he’s acted in a way not expected of him. I’m sure he can be found to be in breach of some code, and I’m in full agreement he should face punishment. Heavy punishment too.

However, neither Elliott or your fictitious teenager, have undertaken any action that brings animal welfare into question. Without any further evidence, neither Elliott or the teenager need take any punishment or even any suggestion of endangering the welfare of an animal.
 
A momentary lack of judgement that shows a distinct lack of class. That is how I would summarise the photo
 
I'm sure if you stood for long enough in a mortuary or a funeral directors with a camera you'd see some things you wish you hadn't.
Though if you were to visit these places with a camera the chances are you already have issues in life....
 
I agree with all that.

He’s been disrespectful, he’s been distasteful, he’s acted in a way not expected of him. I’m sure he can be found to be in breach of some code, and I’m in full agreement he should face punishment. Heavy punishment too.

However, neither Elliott or your fictitious teenager, have undertaken any action that brings animal welfare into question. Without any further evidence, neither Elliott or the teenager need take any punishment or even any suggestion of endangering the welfare of an animal.

Yep.
It depends on where welfare ends though, or how some would define it. which was my point.
In it's broadest sense the people mentioning it would be right.
But I kind of agree with you in that in it's true sense this is nit a welfare issue.

Although there is some fucking mental health welfare issues for sure. But that's all the humans involved, and not the poor horse.
 
Id be of the opinion that the Charles byrnes case was much more damaging for racing.

A horse was given potentially harmful levels of drugs, which couldve harmed the horse or even the jockey, then the horse was laid for serious money.

Yet people were much less vocal about it because it wasn't a big trainer which is wrong.

Gordon has been foolish and disrespectful to the horse and its owners. People are acting as though he killed the horse himself and sat on it like a big game hunter.

A big donation to horse welfare charities and a public apology is as far as I personally think it should go.

Hopefully it is resolved quickly and we dont get a repeat of Byrnes winning a race at the DRF just before being banned.