I like RPR's. They are a useful statistic and provide some interesting discussion points. But, in my view, it is madness that they think that performance was a whole stone better than his Haydock defeat of GDM and Apple Away.
AaronLad I agree. I would have it at 145 at the most.
I think it is fair enough. It was clearly better than a 145 unless you think the 1st, 3rd and 4th all ran below what they had produced on their last run.
If we assume the first four have run to somewhere close to their true form:
4th Crebilly - Won when last seen over hurdles with a career best RPR of 136 (Progressive and unexposed over hurdles). Fell on first start over fences when still travelling behind Ginnys Destiny and given an RPR of 146 & OR of 139.
3rd Trelawne - Lightly raced over hurdles but had won his last two with increasing RPRs, culminating in a 140 (Again progressive and unexposed). Won a handicap on chase debut off a mark of 136 getting an RPR of 146 and OR 143.
1st Ginnys Destiny - More exposed over hurdles with a RPR high of 136. However, had won his previous start in a handicap off a mark of 133 and given an RPR of 147 and on official rating of 141.
If Grey Dawning had run to a 145 then that means Ginnys Destiny has 142, Trelawne 137 and Crebilly 133, 5lb, 9lb and 13lb below what they had all achieved on their last start.
The assumption would therefore be that with the weight allowances as well that Trelawne has marginally improved from his win, probably from running against a higher standard of opposition. Crebilly has run slightly below par, possibly wanting a confidence building run following his fall last time out and Ginnys Destiny is progressive over fences and has improved again, jumping immaculately. Considering Grey Dawning was carrying 3lb more than the first and was beat less than a length then he should be rated 3lb higher and the 'moral' victor of the race.
That would be my take on it.