• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

2024 Novice Chasers

Apple Away looked decent enough today but unfortunately she had little in the way of opposition.

For some context, the horse in 2nd today, although beat 31 lengths, was beat by a 123 rated horse on his chase debut by 6 lengths and lower rated horses in the race too. The 3rd was hammered 16 lengths on chase debut by a horse who then got hammered over 20 lengths by Broadway Boy who in turn got beat by Flooring Porter on chase debut.

In my opinion it was probably one of the easiest beginners chase races for horses who are potentially going to make up into festival horses.

She done all she could, but she's not on my radar for the BANC. She should have been winning on debut too, for me, she was favourably weighted.
 
Surely Marine Nationale (presume you mean him) is all over the Arkle based on comments today? Inthepocket could be in no mans land between the Arkle and Turners. Really looking forward to the second runs coming up for many horses.

Indiana Dream is the interesting one imo with such potential after only 3 races. The BANC and Turners both look laden with talent. Think I've inadvertently taken a book approach this year.

​

Sorry, meant more that Inthepocket and Marine Nationale are going for the same novice chase. If ITP was to beat MN in that, would next step still be DRF for MN? Or, would they look to get a win into him first in January before DRF then Cheltenham.
 
It could be interesting but I guess with that being Mariner's first time out they may not put too much weight on losing, unless by a way. I reckon Marine would stick to the same planned pathway given the confidence in him
 
Apple Away looked decent enough today but unfortunately she had little in the way of opposition.

For some context, the horse in 2nd today, although beat 31 lengths, was beat by a 123 rated horse on his chase debut by 6 lengths and lower rated horses in the race too. The 3rd was hammered 16 lengths on chase debut by a horse who then got hammered over 20 lengths by Broadway Boy who in turn got beat by Flooring Porter on chase debut.

In my opinion it was probably one of the easiest beginners chase races for horses who are potentially going to make up into festival horses.

She done all she could, but she's not on my radar for the BANC. She should have been winning on debut too, for me, she was favourably weighted.

Great post COD. Proper red herring performance that one IMO. I said I wouldn't back AA for the BANC at 50/1 over the summer and at no point throughout the season so far has that view changed. Backers will obviously take encouragement from a 30L win which is fair enough but the context you provide wouldn't have it near BANC standard IMO
 
Apple Away looked decent enough today but unfortunately she had little in the way of opposition.

For some context, the horse in 2nd today, although beat 31 lengths, was beat by a 123 rated horse on his chase debut by 6 lengths and lower rated horses in the race too. The 3rd was hammered 16 lengths on chase debut by a horse who then got hammered over 20 lengths by Broadway Boy who in turn got beat by Flooring Porter on chase debut.

In my opinion it was probably one of the easiest beginners chase races for horses who are potentially going to make up into festival horses.

She done all she could, but she's not on my radar for the BANC. She should have been winning on debut too, for me, she was favourably weighted.

That race was a handicap running off 133, so beat just over 6 lengths gives it running to around 128. The handicapper dropped him by 1lb for it. If he has run to around the 128 again then Apple Away has ran to at least her 141 hurdles mark if not a little higher. Obviously small field races are hard to assess as it just takes a couple not to run to form for the result to flatter the winner. However, it's not as though Apple Away was 1/10 and the runner up was with a small yard. It was Evens-6/4 the pair and a Paul Nicholls runner making his second start over fences having been progressive in 6 hurdle starts. Her debut run was 3rd behind Galliard Du Mesnil, the NH Winner and Grey Dawning who had fitness on his side and was very impressive. Connections have also said that the graduation chase wasn't ideal, especially over a trip too short, but they wanted to get a run into her after two previous attempts were aborted due to the weather. Grade 1 hurdles winner but like all of them, they still have something to prove over fences. Her 7lb allowance though could be valuable considering I don't think there will be much between several of them.
 
It was a similar standard of race to Klassical Dreams

Won very well but beat absolutely nothing

Learn more next time

Chucking her in on debut against grey dawning and GDM wasn't exactly great race planning

Much like running Giovinco in the kauto star shortly after his very hard race against stay away fay will likely end up being.

And running Ahoy senor a horse with jumping problems in a race like the coral gold cup.

They know much more about horses/racing than me but I could definitely map out better races for those horses than they have this season. :angel:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Exar Essay
Great post COD. Proper red herring performance that one IMO. I said I wouldn't back AA for the BANC at 50/1 over the summer and at no point throughout the season so far has that view changed. Backers will obviously take encouragement from a 30L win which is fair enough but the context you provide wouldn't have it near BANC standard IMO

I don't think anyone would be making a case she'll win a Bancs on the back of today's race tbh. Lucinda was just getting her out again for some fencing experience.

I think it would be unwise to completely dismiss her. She won well enough at Aintree last year. SAF had a clean passage throughout the race, there wasn't any hard luck stories in running for him. The only thing you could say is maybe he bounced, but I'd not be sure that was the case, Maximilian beat him twice last term similar distances and there was some decent horses in behind that have franked that form this term. He's 5/1 at the moment the mare can be backed at four times the price.

I'd also add Lucinda's horses tend to come on as the season progresses I don't think they'd have been overly disappointed with her first time out despite the fact she was well beat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Exar Essay and Eggs
[h=2]25Nov23 Haydock (21.5Sft, RPR 120)


​
For a first run over fences Apple Away has performed brilliantly. She's been clever in front of a fence, she's got plenty of scope, she needs an extra half mile at least, if not a mile. She's just been outpaced - Lucinda Russell, trainer.

Says it all about Apple's Away really.


​[/h]
 
I don't think anyone would be making a case she'll win a Bancs on the back of today's race tbh. Lucinda was just getting her out again for some fencing experience.

I think it would be unwise to completely dismiss her. She won well enough at Aintree last year. SAF had a clean passage throughout the race, there wasn't any hard luck stories in running for him. The only thing you could say is maybe he bounced, but I'd not be sure that was the case, Maximilian beat him twice last term similar distances and there was some decent horses in behind that have franked that form this term. He's 5/1 at the moment the mare can be backed at four times the price.

I'd also add Lucinda's horses tend to come on as the season progresses I don't think they'd have been overly disappointed with her first time out despite the fact she was well beat.

I must be unwise, but she's so easy to dismiss ............ I mean come on, really, Apples Away :indecisiveness:




Absolutely no chance. She's not even in the conversation. She hasn't beaten a horse that'd be shorter than 100/1 in a BANC has she?

Only horse she's met that would is Grey Dawning, who walloped her 14L


Absolutely pie in the sky to fancy her for a BANC ..... No one that didn't back her before she ran would fancy her, it's confirmation bias and she's just not good enough. Move on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Quevega
….i’ll be keeping an eye on this fella today;

Spanish Harlem
5g Spanish Moon - Souverainete
Dr SP Fitzgerald
1322P-
RPR 130h OR 131h

‘When we bought him chasing was always what we were looking forward to, so he'll go novice chasing. He looks a stayer to me. He's shaping up nicely, jumps well, so is probably going to be a Brown Advisory sort. I think he's a real nice type. He got a full summer out at grass with us, which did him the world of good, and I think we might see him fulfilling his potential this season.​‘

I remember in last years Stable Tour Mullins saying he was all about chasing, Even then I got the impression they liked him.
 
Cheers Eggs. Another BANC horse !!!

Landrake is a big price for that race isn't he?? Trained by Gord who can't do anything wrong ATM and has had a run.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Eggs
Cheers Eggs. Another BANC horse !!!

Landrake is a big price for that race isn't he?? Trained by Gord who can't do anything wrong ATM and has had a run.

I seen you say this the other day and didn't bother commenting.

77 runners 14 winners 18% strike rate-----Last 14 days.

He can do wrong ok.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carnage at Taunton
I seen you say this the other day and didn't bother commenting.

77 runners 14 winners 18% strike rate-----Last 14 days.

He can do wrong ok.

Yep now willies are arriving at the track fitter Gordon is no longer getting his own way and race fitness is becoming less and less of an issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carnage at Taunton
Blood destiny will need to have calmed down to be getting 2m4f on this ground today
 
Serious performance that.. Could easily drop back to 2m with the way he was jumping them too
 
Blood destiny will need to have calmed down to be getting 2m4f on this ground today

Looked a very competent performance to me. Heart Wood is race fit and was put away before the second last. Beat him at least as easily as Grangeclare West. A drift before the off about BD too which suggests he'll come on for it.
 
I must be unwise, but she's so easy to dismiss ............ I mean come on, really, Apples Away :indecisiveness:




Absolutely no chance. She's not even in the conversation. She hasn't beaten a horse that'd be shorter than 100/1 in a BANC has she?

Only horse she's met that would is Grey Dawning, who walloped her 14L


Absolutely pie in the sky to fancy her for a BANC ..... No one that didn't back her before she ran would fancy her, it's confirmation bias and she's just not good enough. Move on.

Not even in the conversation, what was you smoking last night?

Fwiw there's no bias towards the horse, I haven't had a penny on her. I'm merely looking at the horses profile. She's already beat the current favourite over hurdles. Lucinda's are rarely ready to win first time up if they have bigger assignments down the road. It shouldn't have been a shock a race fit Grey Dawning beat her. Especially the way Dan's are running second time out.

We don't even need to go back that far for an example. Just look at Ahoy Senors debut over fences after winning the Sefton the previous year. Off the back of that effort you could have come to the conclusion he had no chance. He ended up finishing a good 2nd in the Bancs.

​​​​​​0% chance sounds a bit on the low side Kev :watermelon:
 
….Blood Destiny a best 18-1 Turn with Sky. 16-1 BANC with PP.
 
Just a word of warning regarding Blood Destiny, whilst it was a very nice debut from him, he was getting 8lbs off everything today, something he won't be entitled to come the festival.

At least we don't have to worry about Spanish Harlem being one of Willie's potential top novice chasers either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eudipe
Mullins beginning to slowly take control as December turns towards Christmas. Who'd have thought. Has this ever happened before?

Seriously, that was impressive from Blood Destiny. Jumped like a season chaser, not a novice.