So at the start of the year I had narrowed my fancies down for this race as:
Might Bite
Yorkhill
Our Duke
Obviously
Our Duke 14/1 flopped first time out with excuses and it's unknown how he will fare following surgery on his comeback in February. Signs are encouraging he'll be back for that and Katie Harrington's recent interview on the FFP gave further encouragement on their record of back injuries. A waiting brief though for how he fares in the Irish Gold Cup.
Might Bite and Yorkhill have both have widely different outcomes in their races over Christmas!
Firstly the King George:
Might Bite 4/1F
3 out it looked like Might Bite might of won by a wide margin but Double Shuffle and Tea for Two certainly gave me a fright as they closed near the line. The race had shades of 2016 for me where Thistlecrack too kicked on and looked like he would win comfortably only to be closed at the line with Silviniaco Conti and Tea for Two a close 3 lengths behind. At the time I brushed aside the proximity of the other horses as Tom Scu just easing Thistlecrack down at the line but it's clear that probably wasn't the case in hindsight. So i am slightly wary of rating Might Bite's victory and chances with Double Shuffle and Tea for Two so close. I might end up thinking of the saying "Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me" :very_drunk: but I'm happy to take Nico's view that the horse was idling and had plenty left at the end, his last jump suggested so. This time we of course have the RSA as evidence and there's no way he would have got back up against Whisper without having plenty of stamina in his makeup that day. He's a worthy favourite for the race particularly with what has gone on in Ireland today.
My major worry with the horse though is to me it looks like connections are blunting his biggest assest - which is to go at a relentless gallop and get all horses out of their comfort zone. Something we saw at Kempton in 2016 and in the RSA but not since. Perhaps in ground that was against him on Boxing Day he couldn't do so? and obviously connections know more than me and perhaps that is a suicidal tactic in the Gold Cup (long term at least) but I feel like they are taking away perhaps too much of what sets him apart (a bit like Mullins did with UDS as a novice chaser). He idles and although I think he will dig in at the finish, I don't see him as an out and out stayer so if that distance isn't there after the last, he may find other horse(s) just find a little more.
There's little outside of the winner that I would take forward for the Gold Cup.
Bristol de Mai - No excuses for defeat. Had his go for the race in 2017. Cannot see any better to come. A horse to have onside for the Betfair Chase for the next few years but no more.
Thistlecrack - Actually showed more promise than I expected in 4th but lacks that spark pre injury even if we hyped him up too much. I'm sure he will line up in the Gold Cup in March as I can't see where else they would go (for me he wouldn't have enough speed for the Ryanair anymore). Could place at very best but a long shot in doing so. Personally i'd try and take a slow approach and look at something like the Betway Bowl at Aintree (or another grade 1 3mile chase) and have that as his 'Gold Cup'
Whisper - Will approve with Davy back onboard but he'll never beat Might Bite.
Fox Norton - Will revert back to the Ryanair trip
Double Shuffle & Tea For Two - despite coming second and third, hard to see them involved. 3 miles at Kempton is both of their ideals, not 3m2 at Cheltenham.
Onto the Lexus and my other hope, Yorkhill:
Yorkhill - 20/1
I was surprised he turned out here, particularly once Sizing John was a confirmed runner. But his options are so limited left handed that there was little else they could go for. He had so much against him:
- First time out this season
- First time in open company over fences
- No Ruby onboard
- First time trying 3 miles
- Up against the Gold Cup winner and one of the best 3 mile chases of the season
That I thought it was unlikely he would win, though that would not necessarily be the case in February (Irish Gold Cup) and March where most of the above would no longer apply. Having watched the race back 3 or 4 times now, twice just focusing on Yorkhill I think the Gold Cup dream is over and Mullins would share that view even if he has never nailed down the horse throughout his career:
It's disappointing and i'm not sure he has a career as a three-mile chaser. It's back to the drawing board with him.
As soon as Townend went to the front early on I knew he would never get home being so free and with so much against him today, on first view I gave him the benefit of doubt and even thought if this was still a target then 20/1 could be worth chancing but the more I watch it the worse the run looks. I could
still honestly see how he could win a top 3 mile chase but he would need the perfect ride and perfect circumstances for it to happen and those conditions look slimmer and slimmer (buried in the back of the field with Ruby onboard at a strong gallop) and even if he got them, 3m2 round Cheltenham is probably always going to be out of reach for the horse.
One thing for sure I would certainly be sticking to chasing with the horse. Although slightly exuberant for staying chases there was nothing wrong with his jumping today If he goes Ryanair he beats all. The Champion Chase could be interesting up against a post wind-op Altior who may not have a prep run would be interesting but an onsong Altior would be almost impossible to beat imo. I'm done second guessing the horse though. I except the Gold Cup dream is over and will just wait and see what race my 6/1 any race bet on the horse will get me.
Onto the others in the race...
Sizing John - 8/1
Impossible to assess his performance until we realise the extent of the "abnormalities" are in the next few days. If nothing serious then being pushed out to 8/1 could look big if you are happy to draw a line on this run. For this horse though I have to keep coming back to the record of horses to follow up in the Gold Cup. Plus when you look back at his record over 3 miles
Irish Gold Cup - beating Empire of Dirt who has flopped since and not been out this season. More of That, Carlingford Lough and Road to Riches have also done nothing since. Don Poli (sadly) is not Gold Cup class.
Gold Cup - Minella Rocco has done ok since and Native River is still to come out since but it's arguable it was a poor renewal when you had the likes of More of That and Saphir Du Rheu in 5th and 6th only around 6 lengths back.
Punchestown Gold Cup - Djakadam and Coneygree gave him a real test (albeit he was slightly below par) and there was little between the Three. Doesn't look great since with Djakadam looking to have regressed and Coneygree PU twice.
John Durkan - Full credit to win stepping back down in trip and he looked good but a 7 length beating of Djakadam nothing to shout about anymore?
The following isn't mean to knock the horse for what he has done, he clearly is a very good chaser and he's young, you can only beat what is in front of you BUT you need to either be an exceptional horse to retain a Gold Cup or have a substandard year. The above makes me question whether he is
just a good horse or and great/exceptional horse. I still personally don't think we have either, as good as Sizing John is.
I'd still be siding with one of the novice chasers coming through myself.
Of the others in the race:
Road to Respect - First time hood today. His second behind Outlander in the JNWine Chase may have been reversed on a left handed track and with the hood. Form of 1121 since the Cheltenham win. A festival winner, on the upgrade -
is he still underated at 12/1?
The proximity of Outlander and Balko des Flos in the races he has contested makes me dubious about the strength of the form but both have won big races in the past even if they are just as likely to dissapoint.
Balko des Flos - Available at 66/1 for the Gold Cup. Galway Plate winner and running a good race in Yorkhill's JLT win before he came down but doesn't do it for me as per above with his consistency. See the same for Outlander.
Minella Rocco - he would be the horse I take out the race outside of the winner. But much like I have concerns with Sizing John following up, the same applies to question whether MR can go on better this year. 33/1 is half tempting as an each way proposition but I don't see him as the winner. Running in the green and gold hoops means it's tricky to really judge when the jockey onboard may be fully trying but I still have him as too inconsistent for me. I did post a while back on his record in larger fields where he gets cover off a strong pace though which means you can upgrade his career form with the Gold Cup in mind.
Valseur Lido - A good comeback run but he'll follow a similar path to many Gigginstown runners - ran too many times hoping to pick up a pot every 5/6th race but no chance in the Gold Cup.
Djakadam - After Yorkhill's performance he looks likely to be Mullins only runner in the race but no chance. Looks to have regressed and perhaps so many hard races early on in his career have taken it's toll?
The way the 2 races have worked out the following 3 horses have probably almost "enhanced" their claims be not running this week or at least not had their bubble burst:
Coney Island 12/1 - A lovely and very eye catching run on debut at Ascot recently. The form arguably adds up to none. AdP went far too hard early on and More of That looks gone at the game but both visually and sectionals suggest it was an ideal comeback. 12/1 best price for this race
BUT still 14/1 Any Race William Hill even after today which I have just taken considering the Ryanair could still very much come into play (showed plenty of speed and turn of foot at Ascot)
Disko 20/1 - Much like Coney Island i'm not sure what his comeback run amounts too but it was a trip too short and he did what he had to do. A shame we didn't get to see him in either the King George or Lexus. Plenty going for him from his novice chase year (3rd in hot JLT, form tie in with Our Duke and Coney Island, Anibale Fly beating enhanced yesterday). Very interesting and we should no more next time out.
Native River 12/1 - Much like SJ and MR - hard for me to see why he would win after failing last year but Tizzard was way out of form at the festival last season so his 3rd in the race wasn't too bad and as long as they get him back in enough time, a season targeted around the GC and not handicaps could give him a little extra. Place claims for me but a short enough price.
All in all I had expected a slightly better performance on figures from Might Bite (sectionals suggest it wasn't stand out) but I'm willing to except that soft ground, a change of tactics (more restrained) and his idling at the end may have stopped that happening. Like I said a worthy fav but I do think there could be a few more twists and turns to come in the market between now and March.