• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

Just like an auction, you only need 2 active participants to make a great race.
Sure but the sport primarily exists because of gambling and many punters are put off/feel uneasy by scenarios such as this one. At the point of bet placement there is zero awareness of how exciting the race will turn out to be and it would be interesting to see how much punting volumes are affected when one or two trainers dominate entries (whoever those trainers happen to be). According to google punting volumes are significantly impacted by trainer domination (the two trainers highlighted are AOB and Willie) but I don’t have specific numbers although it feels intuitively right. Purists of course may be less bothered as arguably a good horse is a good horse and an exciting race is an exciting race but I’d say its gambling that ultimately decides the viability of the sport.
 
I guess I’m old-fashioned, but I’m surprised the authorities don’t react to the potential here for manipulation of results. I’m not sure what the solution is but I for one feel uncomfortable with what is happening in the John Durkan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eudipe
It’s not satisfactory for sure
But the main question is who’s to blame?
I’d be reasonably sure at least 4 of willies entries are not just there for a day out
It appears other Irish contenders are looking at haydock instead
Which is understandable given the favourite beat very little last year.
For casual punters it must be perplexing but a lot of racing is confusing for your average punter.
Like having so many non runners when the ground is good😔

“It’s good but that’s not good”
 
It’s not satisfactory for sure
But the main question is who’s to blame?
I’d be reasonably sure at least 4 of willies entries are not just there for a day out
It appears other Irish contenders are looking at haydock instead
Which is understandable given the favourite beat very little last year.
For casual punters it must be perplexing but a lot of racing is confusing for your average punter.
Like having so many non runners when the ground is good😔

“It’s good but that’s not good”
I wonder how much will self regulate on Willies retirement. Will be fascinating to see how Joseph reacts when he does.
 
The JD has been one of the best races over the last few years.

Yeah, Willie will have 6-7 who are there for the run but it delivers a good race

Rather that than highlights of horse race gallops at Newbury, and repeat of Henderson saying he doesn’t not want run his horses over good ground, and then moan he can’t find a race

Slightly pee’d off with this season. Struggling to motivate myself to look a racecard, never mind go racing

Rant over, for now lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: archie
Sure but the sport primarily exists because of gambling and many punters are put off/feel uneasy by scenarios such as this one. At the point of bet placement there is zero awareness of how exciting the race will turn out to be and it would be interesting to see how much punting volumes are affected when one or two trainers dominate entries (whoever those trainers happen to be). According to google punting volumes are significantly impacted by trainer domination (the two trainers highlighted are AOB and Willie) but I don’t have specific numbers although it feels intuitively right. Purists of course may be less bothered as arguably a good horse is a good horse and an exciting race is an exciting race but I’d say its gambling that ultimately decides the viability of the sport.
Look no further than the giant sequoia and florida bay race at the curragh a few months back for an example of why punters would be reluctant to bet on such races.

Imagine backing florida bay and then looking at that bullshit on the screen in front of you. And then on top of that, you witness the obvious corruption post race when not a single thing is done about ronan whelan intentionally easing up to let the stable number one and better stallion prospect win, because nothing can be said to aidan o brien and his jockeys in ireland.
 
You mean like last year when Gaelic Warrior and Fact To File went at it hammer and tongs and gave us a great spectacle.

They did. I also think it was a fact finding mission for Willie last season with the pair. For Gaelic to go like he did and battle on to stay and win was enough to confirm he was enough a stayer for a Gold Cup. Obvious and easy to say now, I know, but looking back it makes sense now.

I wonder if we'll have the same spectacle or even if they both turn up again this season tbh, I'm going with that it won't happen. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Gaelic either doesn't turn up or if he does doesn't win the race.
 
They did. I also think it was a fact finding mission for Willie last season with the pair. For Gaelic to go like he did and battle on to stay and win was enough to confirm he was enough a stayer for a Gold Cup. Obvious and easy to say now, I know, but looking back it makes sense now.

I wonder if we'll have the same spectacle or even if they both turn up again this season tbh, I'm going with that it won't happen. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if Gaelic either doesn't turn up or if he does doesn't win the race.
Think it was quite the opposite.

The durkan was a step backwards after the end of his novice season where they’d tried to teach him to drop the bit and settle more.
After the durkan they needed to get back to be able to settle and travel behind the bridle a bit more. The durkan showed that he can still get carried away with himself.

So via the king George and Irish gold cup and teaching him how to settle again they eventually perfected it on the big day.
 
Think it was quite the opposite.

The durkan was a step backwards after the end of his novice season where they’d tried to teach him to drop the bit and settle more.
After the durkan they needed to get back to be able to settle and travel behind the bridle a bit more. The durkan showed that he can still get carried away with himself.

So via the king George and Irish gold cup and teaching him how to settle again they eventually perfected it on the big day.

I'll have to agree to disagree on this, as a serious lack of brain power is present to go head to head with you on this one :ROFLMAO:

In the words of AI, bye for now ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Quevega

New channel same clowns, but most of us enjoyed watching.
Different rubbish name (obviously due to the break with the Racing Post) but looks the same format.
Money talks. Paddy the poacher.
 
Energy bills going up again by £443 a year in January 😭 think I'm going to pull up stumps for the season and roll with what I've got. Cost of living has just gotten waaaay to much. Either that or take my van off the road 😄
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eggs

New channel same clowns, but most of us enjoyed watching.
Different rubbish name (obviously due to the break with the Racing Post) but looks the same format.
Money talks. Paddy the poacher.
Yeah I enjoyed it. Basically the same in a mock Georgian surround
 
Energy bills going up again by £443 a year in January 😭 think I'm going to pull up stumps for the season and roll with what I've got. Cost of living has just gotten waaaay to much. Either that or take my van off the road 😄
Phew! I was concerned about the shareholders missing out on massive dividends then.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Yosser

New channel same clowns, but most of us enjoyed watching.
Different rubbish name (obviously due to the break with the Racing Post) but looks the same format.
Money talks. Paddy the poacher.
Watched it this morning. It's just a medium for Johnny Dineen to prattle on. The panel they had last week was good along with the discussion with Steve Mellish, but Dave is a presenter, not a tipster, and it is rare Johnny says anything that makes you sit up and take notice. Apparently split the show up into two also so another one is coming out with their ante post tips in.