I think this was mentioned on Road to Cheltenham but what do people think of having a long distance veterans chase (10-y-o or older) at the Festival?
I know there would be an issue of which race to replace but given the change in nature of the National Hunt chase (as a kind of second trial for future Gold Cup horses), I thought that could be the one as we already have a 3m novices chase called the Brown Advisory (former RSA)..
So a handicap for older horses over more than 3 miles with or without amateur riders?
I recall Ruby Walsh was against the idea and he made the comment along the lines that "the handicapper allows for the age of a horse" - that was news to me or was he just leg pulling?
I think it's a terrible idea. I'm not over-keen on them anyway, and to put one on at the Festival would be the biggest turn off imaginable.
There are a number of other things they need to sort out when thinking about how to expand the Festival, before they should even dream of messing around by adding races like this that have no place whatsoever.
Firstly the handicaps are now dominated by unexposed novices. There's a simple solution to that. Make novices ineligible. The by-product of doing so is it opens up the race to genuine handicappers, and pushes the novices back to the novice races where each season the field sizes are reducing.
Then by doing so it opens up the opportunity to expand the number of races by adding novice handicaps (0-145 or even 0-140), rather than non-entity veteran chases, or a 2 mile cross county race, or other such stupid ideas. Those horses rated higher than the handicap limit are now pushed towards the novice championship races if they want a run, which has the consequence of pushing field sizes back to acceptable levels in the graded races.
With those problems solved and longer-term evidence that the graded races are attracting fields and field sizes worthy of the name, a two and half mile championship hurdle could then be considered to fill the obvious gap. Right now though that really can't happen, despite it being an obvious move to mirror the chases.
I accept the inevitability of a 5 day Festival, and whilst I'd very much prefer not, I would accept it if there was a clearly thought out plan to add to the spectacle, and not to take away from it. And to use the move to solve some very obvious problems.
In addition to this I also have an issue with the mares allowance which is causing an obvious imbalance. Take Honeysuckle for example, who is perfectly capable of mixing it with the boys, with or without and allowance. Every times she wins a Grade 1 reduce her allowance by 2lbs, and if she wins a Grade 1 reduce it by a 1lb. That simple mechanism should be applied to all mares running in open graded races. Simple really, but seemingly beyond the collective brains that run horseracing to solve what is a very basic issue.