IMO A Plus Tard was a graded horse running in a handicap last year and on a line through duc des genievres he'd have won the arkle. I agree about handicappers turning into graded horses is rare but to call A Plus Tard a handicapper for running in one and bolting up is harsh.
He was beaten in a grade 2 getting lumps of weight, then won a handicap?
He certainly wasn't at the level he'd need to be to beat Min.
This year, it's easier in hindsight to say he was graded class as his win over CPS got franked (as he beat Min).
They're the right two at the top of the market, but I'd have them the other way around.
To be fair calling him a handicapper last year is a bit much, fair enough