• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

….in their Specials section, Hills have Top Jockey & Top Trainer markets if anybody is interested.
 
I often edit my last post with updates that are not time critical. totally conscious myself of spamming "post it notes" in effect.


Anyway.
I don't think there is a need for anyone else to acknowledge or explain themselves.
I didn't mention it for that reason.
People will read it and take it for what it is.
They may do things differently or they may not.
Free world.

Firstly I feel like a fraud as I do not provide a diary so accept I’m not really qualified to comment but one thought did strike me as I was reading through your original post. Perhaps it is the vulnerable themselves that are most likely to want their book to appear more positive than it really is, to fool others and/or fool themselves and as such perhaps a gentle private message from somebody might be in order just to check all is ok?
 
No running total of losses are being kept for many.

This is my biggest issue.

I see 100's of roll up attempts that seem to make no difference to a P/L when, IMO, they are directly linked to getting a horse onside for the festival and should be taken into account with regards to any individuals P/L for the festival.

Unfortunately I don't update any of my P/L until Monday mornings due to family life at the weekend, although sometimes I will remove a horse from a race IF I get time (Shallwehaveonemore this weekend, but haven't been able to update my spreadsheet for P/L yet). What I do notice is I always seem to be sitting with some of the biggest pre festival losses on my diary, compared with many, this includes last year as well, and I can't believe I'm the only one who has these sorts of losses, despite my scattergun approach and faffing around :highly_amused:

I know one thing I don't do, and that's list individual stakes as I back a horse, but I did do a breakdown of race by race before the festival last season to show where I'm at, which I will most probably do again this coming festival.

It's each to their own of course, and unfortunately people are only cheating themselves and to potentially make themselves look better than they actually are. But then I think you most likely have some sort of issue if you feel the need to do this in the first place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjy23
The diaries these days in the members section are generally a fucking disgrace.

I'll not call out individual members but the aftertiming has become common place (I get that it's not always possible for those that have a life)
But it renders them untrustworthy IMO, so the adding up after the event and backslapping (which happens annually now) becomes tedious. IMO.

Diaries are being edited with bets added and taken away, and no comments/records made.
No running total of losses are being kept for many.
Some even show last years results on a race by race basis with no mention/record of losses occurred in the run up.
Some don't even include stakes so what's the fucking point in that ?

I kind of mentioned this last year, and it's got worse.
I'm not calling individual people out as I think that would be unfair and there are so many.
But some very notable individuals are 'guilty'.

I kind of don't care on a personal level other than it's irritating and the competitive element is long gone, if ti ever was there, as everyone's methods are different - and I've stopped looking at them most of the time,

But (and this is the important bit) there are people who are heavily influenced in the gambling world (vulnerable gamblers I'd call them) and it irritates me when things are misrepresented, deliberately or through lack of care.

I know for a fact that there are many "vulnerable's" who are members on here and those that aren't, who visit the site.

So misleading information can do damage whether it's by design or not.


This is just my opinion only, and you can obviously do what you want.
Thought it worth mentioning.


Much easier for you to say with 11k posts than me but it's something I did pick up on. Tend to ignore the points and prices parts in the diaries and just read people's write ups, if there is one. To avoid the desire to call any out! There's some really good content in a lot of them but I can't be taking the numbers too seriously.
​​​​​​Also agree with the above. I'm not convinced on the use of roll-ups in general though to be honest. Was going to post about this in the discussion on points systems and betting banks the other day but bottled it.
 
Much easier for you to say with 11k posts than me but it's something I did pick up on. Tend to ignore the points and prices parts in the diaries and just read people's write ups, if there is one. To avoid the desire to call any out! There's some really good content in a lot of them but I can't be taking the numbers too seriously.
​​​​​​Also agree with the above. I'm not convinced on the use of roll-ups in general though to be honest. Was going to post about this in the discussion on points systems and betting banks the other day but bottled it.

On the roll up side, I'm really looking forward to seeing my results and discussing them with everyone. It's my first year doing them and it's currently taken approximately 1/5 of my betting bank to put myself in a position where if flooring porter, American Mike or journey with me win, I can't lose at the festival. I also would have had run wild Fred but I cashed him out pre-troytown and SWIW if she hadn't got injured (managed to cash her out though). I've got all the stats on mine so far but think it's best to discuss them post-cheltenham when all results are known for every horse. :encouragement:​​​​​​
 
Each to their own, people are only kidding themselves ultimately, most are fine and some in particular are admirably honest, but it does feel like some are a bit liberal with the truth on roll-ups. The other one is on numerous occasions i've noticed claims to have cashed out for full stakes (particularly post race) that don't make an awful lot of sense.
My own diary is a total out of date mess mostly because I can't be arsed, life gets in the way and I have all the figures and a solid handle on what's what in my head. I'll be sitting down to sort it this week though as we're in a quiet racing spell, it's important IMO to know exactly where you stand figures wise with a view to the following season as much as anything, and i've managed to bribe someone with fish and chips to be my admin for a few hours...
The temptation to wind Quevega up with some absolutely sickening after-timing is always there though and I couldn't put anyone off.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Quevega
Blimey. These are very long posts. I’ve had to open a second barley wine before getting to the end.
I love the posts on this forum, but I’m only a simple orthopaedic surgeon and often need posts with few syllables and a single content to keep me on track
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eudipe and Eggs
I am a bit guilty of this, my diary is quite messy in that I just havent bothered to remove all my dead multiples and singles, i.e Appreciate It and hence haven't added it to my profit / loss.

Really should go through it when I have time and sort that out to be honest
 
I often edit my last post with updates that are not time critical. totally conscious myself of spamming "post it notes" in effect.


Anyway.
I don't think there is a need for anyone else to acknowledge or explain themselves.
I didn't mention it for that reason.
People will read it and take it for what it is.
They may do things differently or they may not.
Free world.

The diaries are a pain in the arse. They were a good idea to start with but the up keep of them is a real chore.

I think they were brought in to (partly) stop after timing but the roll up brings about a whole different world of after timing:barbershop_quartet_member:

Do you think anyone would follow a diary blind? I'd really hope not.

I do keep checking to see which horses you're backing at monster prices on the exchanges. Taking of which, what about Hitman for the Ryanair? He's 80.0, which I just nibbled at.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf
Go to the Kemble brewery. Sit in front of the fire , ogle barmaids tits and get a nice pint of black rat.
that’ll do you much better than a fiver on hitman. You know it makes sense
 
Go to the Kemble brewery. Sit in front of the fire , ogle barmaids tits and get a nice pint of black rat.
that’ll do you much better than a fiver on hitman. You know it makes sense

Too late:excitement:. I'll be able to buy 80 pints of black rat (what is that?) When PFN has Hitman trained to perfection and he scoots up:devilish:
 
Did there not used to be a thread/message along the lines of the 'safety' messages from bookies.
 
Potential stupid question: Is there a reason Gabynako hasn't been given a handicap Chase mark?
 
Potential stupid question: Is there a reason Gabynako hasn't been given a handicap Chase mark?

Almost certainly because he has yet to be entered for a handicap chase. The handicapper will have a mark for him (and is likely to let trainer know if/when asked) but it won't be published until he is entered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamieSensible
The diaries are a great part of the site. Before they started loads of threads were clogged with "good post I'll put 2pts on that" posts. So now we have a great dynamic whereby we have a section people can document their actual betting and strategies, while the main forum threads are broadly are discussions of the races with occasional #PotatoPosting. Incidences of after timing dramatically decreased post diaries starting.

I subscribe to people's diaries whose approaches I find interesting, which is a great feature of the site - so I get a notification when there's a post.

The roll up issue is done to death, there's advocates on both sides and I guess we'll never fully agree on them.

I'll admit I've been pretty sloppy at posting in mine on an ongoing manner, but I update my full post one every Monday with live cashed and lost point totals. Now AV has a point, you're only kidding yourself- I'm very transparent in mine and everyones thoughts are therefore very useful. So I'm not casting the first stone for timeliness, but accuracy and editing are worrying.

Tone and standards are very important in digital spaces, less they descend into uselessness. Horse racing is a world filled with blaggarts, blowhards and bullshitters - what makes this place special is that its a place of debate, evidence and critical thinking (and, in the style of the Avengers "we have a Lobos " ). We already had a poster who kept belittling what someone's real world stakes might be. While I was just the other day remarking about the forum self aggrandising, it is important we uphold those standards to keep the magic going imo. So fair play to Q for calling it out
 
  • Like
Reactions: Quevega
What's the name of the person associated with Robcour who answers DMs quite honestly?

I thought it was Brian Acheson himself but noticed I can't message him (unless that says more about me!)
 
I know in past years alot of short priced favourites get turnt over at the festival..but last years festival alot of well backed favourites went in..i think that was down to the irish being very dominant but this year i think feels similar, bookies were alot shorter on many horses at the start of the season then they have been before and alot of favourites already look quite solid across most races does anyone think there could be a repeat of this festival just gone, where alot of favs actually fly in? I can see it personally
all these look solid to me;
gallopin des champs
bob olinger
ferny hollow
honeysuckle
RWF (if he goes)
allaho
the top 2 in the betting in the champ bumper
and vauban of course hands and heels job!
 
The bookies will get a few of those beat don't worry about that. 3 out of that group will be a great return.
 
I know in past years alot of short priced favourites get turnt over at the festival..but last years festival alot of well backed favourites went in..i think that was down to the irish being very dominant but this year i think feels similar, bookies were alot shorter on many horses at the start of the season then they have been before and alot of favourites already look quite solid across most races does anyone think there could be a repeat of this festival just gone, where alot of favs actually fly in? I can see it personally
all these look solid to me;
gallopin des champs
bob olinger
ferny hollow
honeysuckle
RWF (if he goes)
allaho
the top 2 in the betting in the champ bumper
and vauban of course hands and heels job!

I think your wrong about last year reckon almost more got beat last year than won out of the short price favs, concertista,chacun,easysland,kilcruit,envoi, zanahiry, elimay all got beat at very short odds and the likes of Appreciate it, shishkin, Honeysuckle, Bob o and monkfish won, happens most years imo some win some don't
 
Managed to cash out a couple of bets I had from start of season that had Jeff Kidder in.
Thank you Madmoose for posting on the out of festival thread.
I owe you a drink!!