I’ve absolutely no issue with him not being the best judge as he’s there to present the show and keep it ticking over, but he spends SO LONG airing his views about horses and form that he ends up taking more time analysing or previewing the races than his guests.
As you rightly point out, he drops a factual clanger into every episode and can never backup or justify his opinions anyway, which is fine as that’s not really his job - but get on with it in that case! His guests are generally great, always keen to hear what Paul Ferguson has to say in particular, but when the host frequently just barks outlandish statements and leaves them hanging like an errant fart it makes it obviously awkward for the guests.
I’ve stopped listening since he spent the entire show monotonously asking David Pipe the same question about every single horse in his stable, and then proceeded to just interrupt Kate Tracey for the rest of the show. In fairness to him, he’s got a fairly big listenership - and I’d hate to imagine the less constructive abuse that gets directed his way on Twitter...