• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

Kevloaf and all mods, perhaps this is something for 2023 but a few months ago I mentioned an idea that was well received - introducing threads to discuss targets and encouraging all conversations about targets to happen in those threads. Could be as straightforward as two threads on novice hurdlers and chasers, but I think a place away from the main threads for these debates to happen will prevent the main threads becoming diluted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Bucks
Kevloaf and all mods, perhaps this is something for 2023 but a few months ago I mentioned an idea that was well received - introducing threads to discuss targets and encouraging all conversations about targets to happen in those threads. Could be as straightforward as two threads on novice hurdlers and chasers, but I think a place away from the main threads for these debates to happen will prevent the main threads becoming diluted.

Start them up now if you like, can see how it goes?
 
Start them up now if you like, can see how it goes?

I suspect the ship has already sailed and it will need a firm hand of mods to enforce this. Let's try it for next year, be so worth while IMO
 
I think its an excellent idea Charlie, I'm guilty of it too, but it seems to be the same shit spouted off time and time again about who goes where, repetitively annoying and boring. I understand (imo) it is one of the hardest to predict in recent years where the Novices are going to end up with so many horses having the entries and nothing set it stone bar a few obvious ones were exactly they are going to run. But the same conversations or similar posts about a horse target, and debates can get really tedious.

It might not work, but I think it's worth a shot. I think traffic is pretty big at the minute and can understand members missing other posts maybe that's already been said (including these type of comments, but my main concern is we might miss decent posts that interest us due to these types of comments.

Members might like to hear insight of where members feel the horses are going to run, so they have the option to go to this new thread to read or add to it.

Waffled a bit there but hope that makes sense if agree with it or not!
 
Personally, I thought we gave up on the broad category threads (novice hurdles, chases etc) a tad too early - but that doesn't really stop the repetition cycle we've seen at this stage of the season this year. Could just be a one off though given the large amount of options this year?
 
Could a solution be to keep the general Novice Chase, Novice Hurdle, Chase, Hurdle etc. threads in the general section and to have race specific threads in the members section?
 
I have two Cheltenham Tats Club tickets for the 3rd day (Thursday) of the fez.Ryanair and Stayers Hurdle day. ?95 each (face value). Please p.m. me if of interest.

BARGAIN OF THE FEZ. ?150 FOR THE PAIR.. plus post. ( Now ?100 each on Cheltenham site plus fee)

Bumped for interest
 
Last edited:
I suspect the ship has already sailed and it will need a firm hand of mods to enforce this. Let's try it for next year, be so worth while IMO

Perhaps...... just thinking about this, getting a team of mods enforcing what can and can't be discussed within the specifics of every single thread (rather than just a general rule of 'keep it about racing') is a helluva of a big ask isn't it?

I wouldn't ask to do the mods anything I wouldn't be willing to do, and respectfully I feel I have better things to do than read every single post in every thread in 'real time' and have to move it or remind someone not to discuss targets beacuse it's going to be unavoidable in some cases anyway?

This is me just thinking out loud though :culpability: charlie Big Bucks

I agree with robith the specific threads did go up too early this year, we were out voted .... but essentially, we'd still end up with the same content wouldn't we, so not really sure it's a fixable problem (problem probably not even the right word)?
 
Perhaps...... just thinking about this, getting a team of mods enforcing what can and can't be discussed within the specifics of every single thread (rather than just a general rule of 'keep it about racing') is a helluva of a big ask isn't it?

I wouldn't ask to do the mods anything I wouldn't be willing to do, and respectfully I feel I have better things to do than read every single post in every thread in 'real time' and have to move it or remind someone not to discuss targets beacuse it's going to be unavoidable in some cases anyway?

This is me just thinking out loud though :culpability: charlie Big Bucks

I agree with robith the specific threads did go up too early this year, we were out voted .... but essentially, we'd still end up with the same content wouldn't we, so not really sure it's a fixable problem (problem probably not even the right word)?

Yeh logistically it sounds like a nightmare, but I genuinely think if those threads existed people would use them and understand why they exist.

Was just an idea, one for 2023 maybe
 
Comments in the Supreme thread about the ride My Mate Mozzie got yesterday, made me look at Gavin Cromwell’s performance over the weekend. He had 3 runners in total.

On Saturday, Pour Pavore in the 3m handicap hurdle, never troubled the judge and came in as he liked, 11/24 at 28/1. This horse bagged the all-important 6[SUP]th[/SUP] place in the Pertemps qualifier where there was more focus on Dunboyne and Winter Fog over Christmas at Leopardstown. 33-40 ante post, 25/1 NRNB with Bet 365.

His other runner, Brides Hill, was much more fancied, at 11/1, in Sunday’s mares handicap hurdle, where Party Central was the handicap snip. She’d previously demolished a good field over Christmas, also at Leopardstown. After disputing the lead, and running off top weight, she went out like a light at the final turn, and was quickly pulled up.

As for My Mate Mozzie, Gavin did say she’d be back on song for a spring campaign. Still holds the Champion Hurdle entry and while that seemed very optimistic at the time, I suspect Gavin was just using the DRF to give these 3 a blow out before spring campaigns.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deleted member 4957
Currently, in exact order who do we think is the top 5 most likely (no such thing as a banker) winners at Cheltenham then? I might have 3 in right order here :wink-new:

1. Honeysuckle
2. Allaho
3. Shishkin
4. GDC
5. Facile Vega
 
Currently, in exact order who do we think is the top 5 most likely (no such thing as a banker) winners at Cheltenham then? I might have 3 in right order here :wink-new:

1. Honeysuckle
2. Allaho
3. Shishkin
4. GDC
5. Facile Vega

No Bob Olinger? Think I’d have him in there over Facile Vega.
 
Currently, in exact order who do we think is the top 5 most likely (no such thing as a banker) winners at Cheltenham then? I might have 3 in right order here :wink-new:

1. Honeysuckle
2. Allaho
3. Shishkin
4. GDC
5. Facile Vega

1. Honeysuckle
2. Allaho
3. Constitution Hill (based this on DD going Ballymore)
4. Bob Olinger
5. Galopin Des Champs
 
  • Like
Reactions: BalthazarKing