There are many posts focussing on what punishment Gordon Elliott should receive and many are providing thorough and compelling arguments for the need to understand cultural and environmental factors when reaching that judgement. I can completely understand this, it may well be right but it is completely irrelevant to the big picture. The exact nature of his punishment is only relevant to him and those in one way or another connected to him.
whether he is treated punitively or leniently will not matter that much in the big picture of things. The world now thinks that one of the most gifted respected and successful trainers has no respect for animals. That train has left the station. It takes a lifetime to gain a reputation and a nano second to lose it. Much as we might want the world to stop and understand and wait to hear all the relevant and mitigating evidence the world will not do that. That is just for internal consumption. The outside world has already made its judgement.
As far as the world is concerned horse racing is a sport where humans gain pleasure from putting animals in life and death situations for pleasure and the images the world has now seen confirms just how clinically and dispassionately those at the vey pinnacle of the sport reconcile the sacrifice these animals are making for our pleasure.. We cannot assume the sport can continue to showcase itself this way and think the world is just going to sit back and let it happen.
the more we get locked into what punishment the trainer should get and think of that as the biggest issue at play here the more we will be guilty once again of thinking we have our own destiny in our own hands. Again I think this is short sightedness of a level so extreme it is making me think the sport will deserve everything it gets.
I haven’t seen anything that even remotely resembles a strategic plan by the sport to deal with the broader ramifications. Everybody seems to be locked into the minutiae and nobody looking outside. The few references I have seen on here to this have been references to the importance of Ed chamberlain doing a good job on Saturday. This is just touching the very edges of things.
I have seen some talk on here of losing sponsors. This is a much bigger issue than what punishment Gordon Elliott receives. How the fuck does the sport attract much needed new sponsors ? How do we think things will go now if a labour government gets in. How do we think this shit storm sets us up to defend affordability checks, how do we think our future attempts to lobby people in Westminster are going to go now and so on and on and on.
A few folks on here have said this is now about PR. Absolutely right, the sport needs to start pulling rabbits out of hats and very fucking soon and the stakes have never been higher imo.