• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

You have the view he'll never train again? Why?

I have the view that he should not be allowed to work with horses again. That is because I have the opinion that we need to be seen to do our upmost to try and rid an animal sport of any sort of cruelty towards those animals and anything that suggests cruelty is happening within the sport, and anyone responsible for this not given the chance to ever do so again.
I hope this happens, I honestly think it’s the best thing for the sport going forward.
 
In the cold light of day, this is basically where i'm at too. I don't excuse any of it for a second and could never personally imagine acting in such a way because i'm such a soft bastard about animals if nothing else and just haven't been brought up like that, but gallows humour among people that regularly have to see dreadful things is nothing new or surprising.
Do I honestly find the photo or video shocking? No, not at all. Sad yes and disappointing, but I can at least understand the context. In the jockey example, he's being actively encouraged to do it (no, I wouldn't jump off a bridge, this is about trying to get inside the thought processes of these people, not excuse it) and sits on it for no more than a couple of seconds, I don't look at it and feel they're seeking to disrespect a dead animal, I look at it and see them thinking what they're doing is making light of the situation. The crime is stupidity and however snobby it sounds, a lack of class and probably education. Does that make it right? Of course it doesn't, it's hugely disrespectful, it's stupid and they should know better and be professional if nothing else. But you'd have to be intensely naive to think it's anything new. The only new element is the cameras and social media.
This is a PR disaster for a sport that at the best of times needs all the good PR it can lay its hands on, but it's one that doesn't on the face of it involve animal welfare. It's deeply unpalatable, but the horse(s) were deceased. It does however raise questions about animal welfare, it's hard to avoid thinking that if some involved show this level of disrespect and are seemingly so desensitised, what else goes on? If there's one good thing to come from all this then hopefully it's that it helps weed the stupid out and that standards are raised higher than ever.

Ultimately we already follow a sport where for our entertainment, horses lose their lives on a regular basis, often due to appalling and gut wrenching injuries, regularly witnessed on live tv. We say our thoughts go out to connections etc... then move on to the next race. We make excuses for it and there is of course a lot of context to be applied, but those are the bare facts and something that regularly makes me question my support, even though I love the sport and understand it.
We watch a sport that has a channel that runs an LGBT advert regularly where the message is that its everyones sport and the LGBT community is welcome in it, which of course it is and they are. Then without a hint of irony we go across to live racing from Meydan and Riyadh, where people fall over themselves to bow to such regimes and fawn over how great it all is for the sport, by which they mean the prize funds on offer which are impossible to ignore. Flat racing in particular falls over itself to accommodate anyone who throws money at it regardless of the dubious nature of that money and the nations it originates from. No shortage of other examples where the sport walks a strange path. The moral high ground is a tricky old thing in this game.

This is a smashing post mate and puts everything into context beautifully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carnage at Taunton
Thanks, I have the opposite view, that’s a forum for you. Anyway whatever our views are we won’t change what is decided. Time will tell .

Taking the emotion out of it and looking at it from a legal perspective, a lifetime ban is extremely unlikely.

Even the IHRB enforce a lifetime ban, it can be appealed to IHRB appeals, and even then that appeal can be taken to CAS, or in extreme cases through National and European Courts.

Sporting penalties must be proportionate to the objective that they pursue and any period of disqualification must be reasonable - this is why athletes wont get lifetime bans for doping offences, the 2 years for 1st offence, 4 for 2nd etc have been ruled and accepted as proportionate to the objective of maintaining a clean sport.

Elliot will be likely be charged with some form of bringing the sport into disrepute using the provisions below, i can't see a case sticking that a lifetime ban is proportionate for taking a crass photograph on a deceased horse particularly when there have been recent cases across BHA and IHRB of: jockey stopping a horse (Callum McKinnes 56 days), Trainers Ordering Jockeys to stop horses (Jim Best 4 years, reduced to 6 months), Trainer negligence leading to a positive doping result (Charles Byrnes 6 months).

If the objective is to preserve the good reputation of horse racing, then a lifetime ban is not reasonable, as it essentially amounts to a permanent restraint of trade which is not proportionate to the offence, particularly when compared to the sanctions handed down to others who have also been seen to cause damage to the interests of horseracing in Ireland or the UK.

RULES OF RACING AND IRISH NATIONAL HUNT STEEPLECHASE RULES 2020

PART XXIII

PRESERVING THE GOOD REPUTATION OF HORSERACING

271. The standard of proof to be applied in all Stewards' Enquiries and in all cases before the Licensing Committee, the Referrals Committee or the Appeals Body shall be the balance of probabilities.

272. Any person involved in horse racing who, within the jurisdiction of the IHRB;
(i) whether verbally or by conduct or behaviour, acts in a manner which is prejudicial to the integrity, proper conduct or good reputation of horseracing (whether or not such behaviour or conduct, verbal or otherwise is associated directly with horseracing);

273 (xii) It shall be a breach of these Rules for any person to do any act which in the opinion of the Referrals Committee or the Appeals Body is likely to be prejudicial to the interests of the IHRB or which is likely to cause serious damage to the interests of horseracing in Ireland whether or not such an act shall otherwise amount to a breach of these Rules or any Regulation or instruction made thereunder
 
Awful couple of days for the sport and would echo the views of many on here.

However just to move onto what it means for Cheltenham. It was mentioned previously not being ideal to change yards so close to Cheltenham (horses getting runny noses etc). Could CP wait it out and move their horses to HDB or WM or whoever, say the day before they are due to travel over. Obviously wouldn't be publicly in their interests to share this plan but at end of the day they have done nothing wrong and deserve the chance for their horses to run and at the same time do everything to ensure as little disruption as possible to their horses preparation.
 
He has posted a few minutes ago saying.


Damaging few days for the sport - yes
Represntitive - No

The accompanying has been reposted a few times and think originates from the account of the stable lass. It has been mentioned that a picture says a thousand words and i think this is one that speaks louder than the stupidity we have seen in the past few days.
 
Quilixios to Willie's.

Envoi Allen, Sir Gerhard, Ballyadam to De Bromhead's
 
Quilixios to Willie's.

Envoi Allen, Sir Gerhard, Ballyadam to De Bromhead's


....not sure if that’s still rumour, but if all turn up in a fortnight the big black cloud over my portfolio will look a little brighter.
 
I have the view that he should not be allowed to work with horses again. That is because I have the opinion that we need to be seen to do our upmost to try and rid an animal sport of any sort of cruelty towards those animals and anything that suggests cruelty is happening within the sport, and anyone responsible for this not given the chance to ever do so again.
I hope this happens, I honestly think it’s the best thing for the sport going forward.

I think that's all ok if there was actually cruelty, which there wasn't....

There's no doubt it painted a horrible picture of racing though.

To ban a man for life for effectively a crude and tasteless joke is way way over the top though.