• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

Arkle 2018

The dilema is that Mullins compared him favouribly to any other novice chaser he has had.
You can't put a figure or literal worth to those comments, but I certainly took notice and think it is justifiably factored in to his price.

I think because he was a juvenile they decided to spend an extra year over hurdles... in a bit of a nothing year, testing out his stamina and so on... and so I think you have to take that in to account when this year he does look a different animal.

I know I use this a lot, but Sprinter Sacre wasn't the same horse over hurdles that he was over fences... and Footpad seems to be the same kind of horse.... whether or not he goes on to challenge in Champion Chases and so on I wouldn't like to be bold about... but plenty do improve when changing from hurdles to fences and Footpad looks to be just that.
 
I haven't checked back but, from memory, I think that Willie said that Footpad jumped as well as any novice he'd had rather something more overwhelming.
 
Footpad is 3 4 3 on ground with good in the description.

That for me is a worry, I watched the last race again and is PM closing hard at the line or is FP being pulled up, or is it a bit of both?
 
I haven't checked back but, from memory, I think that Willie said that Footpad jumped as well as any novice he'd had rather something more overwhelming.




After race at*Leopardstown Sat, 3rd Feb, 2018 (1st)**He did it the hard way and jumped well in front. I think he pecked a bit at the last but it was a very good performance. We didn’t set out to make it but Paul wasn’t happy that there was enough pace so he went on. We are heading for the Arkle unless something else changes. He was fourth in a Champion Hurdle but we thought he would be going two and a half miles or more over fences. The first day he jumped he was very good and when you can jump you can go any trip. Demi Sang made a hash of the first fence and lost his confidence a bit so David tried to get him back jumping and he did. It would be hard to see him competing at Grade 1 level over two miles so he’ll probably have to drop down a Grade or go out in trip. I would prefer to go out in trip but we’ll have a word with Frank (Berry) and JP (McManus) and see what they want to do.**

W P MullinsAfter race at*Leopardstown Tue, 26th Dec, 2017 (1st)**He's electric. From the first day at home that I saw him jumping over fences I thought he was the best I've seen for a long while. He was good on his debut at Navan but today he was just awesome. He gained lengths at his fences and he's one to really look forward to. I'd imagine he'd come back here for a similar type of race at the new Dublin Festival of Racing (Leopardstown, February 3-4) and then, hopefully fingers crossed and everything stays right, on to Cheltenham.**



W P MullinsAfter race at*Navan Sun, 12th Nov, 2017 (1st)**it was a good performance; he is a very natural jumper at home and he did the same here. He's as good as novice as I've seen schooling at home and I thought it was a good performance for a first time out novice. I'd imagine we'll look at the Drinmore; the way he was going there I'd be happy to stick at two miles but the Drinmore is two-and-a-half so we'll look at that. He has no problem going two-and-a-half as he was a two-and-a-half mile hurdler. He is so well balanced jumping and is a complete natural.**W P Mullins
 
Footpad is 3 4 3 on ground with good in the description.

That for me is a worry, I watched the last race again and is PM closing hard at the line or is FP being pulled up, or is it a bit of both?

Footpad could have won that race on that day. As far as townend wanted to after the last

Look at the quality of those races he ran in. They were also over hurdles
 
Last edited:
I don't think there will be much between footpad and sceau royal, daryl jacob chose sceau royal over footpad last year and to be fair was finishing on his heels up the straight. Also Ruby's comments about the 'the more juice in the ground the better his chance's ' regarding footpad in last year's champion. ........Now I'm not saying Footpad doesn't handle good ground, he clearly does, and he has improved for fences but he must be a 5lb better horse over soft ground and that might be enough for sceau to get past him, who also has improved for bigger obstacles too....Just an opinion and looking forward to a great race
 
I don't think there will be much between footpad and sceau royal, daryl jacob chose sceau royal over footpad last year and to be fair was finishing on his heels up the straight. Also Ruby's comments about the 'the more juice in the ground the better his chance's ' regarding footpad in last year's champion. ........Now I'm not saying Footpad doesn't handle good ground, he clearly does, and he has improved for fences but he must be a 5lb better horse over soft ground and that might be enough for sceau to get past him, who also has improved for bigger obstacles too....Just an opinion and looking forward to a great race

With all due respect Jacob diddnt choose sceau royal. He diddnt have the option of footpad.
 
Yes that's what I always thought too, jacob was retained by the owners for their English runners, however Jacobs himself recently said that there have been no jockey confirmations regarding the Arkle, which I thought just meant that they were waiting on Ruby but then racing UK published a piece on the Arkle 2 weeks ago saying that Jacobs has the choice of the pair of them,sceau or footpad.
 
Yes that's what I always thought too, jacob was retained by the owners for their English runners, however Jacobs himself recently said that there have been no jockey confirmations regarding the Arkle, which I thought just meant that they were waiting on Ruby but then racing UK published a piece on the Arkle 2 weeks ago saying that Jacobs has the choice of the pair of them,sceau or footpad.

He said completely the opposite after he rode footpad ireland. :)
 
I see this as a 3 horse race between FP, PM & SC.

FP - Is down 3-1 versus PM. Granted up 1-0 over fences. We have seen the Mullins quotes on his jumping. Has beat everything easily. Good festival form, just not bomb proof for me at the moment. I plan to look at the sectionals from all his races v PM tonight.

PM - Seemed to make an abundance of mistakes over hurdles and made a few early v Footpad at Leopardstown last time, doesn't seem to stop his momentum though. As stated is currently 3-1 up against Footpad and would not have been on favourable terms for the defeat last time, giving he was coming off an injury. I think everyone can expect improvement from him, but horses with an interrupted preparation at the festival I usually tend to avoid.

SC - Looked super impressive so far although the form is probably not rock solid but his jumping has been very good and I would love to be on at 100/1 like some here. Ground would be my big worry for him and he certainly has a lack of experience of being in a battle compared to FP & PM.
 
Jacob confirmed in Jan on On the Line with Chapman that he rides SR and Ruby Footpad.

Bromley earlier in the season -

Anthony Bromley, racing manager for owners Simon Munir and Isaac Souede said: “It was lovely to see. It wasn’t a total surprise as the horse has got great form over hurdles and he was always going to be a nice chaser. The manner of it was great.”

He went on: “It will be up to Willie (where he goes), but I imagine he will be campaigned between two and two and a half miles and then see where we go. It will fit around with what else he has got.

“I was pleased Daryl (Jacob, retained rider) got the chance to ride him as he rode him in most races last season as he was always the second or third string in the Grade Ones in the Mullins yard. When Ruby (Walsh) had a sore hand, it was nice Daryl could go and ride him.

“Whether he will get back on him is another thing as I imagine he will be first choice in that division now.
 
Jacob confirmed in Jan on On the Line with Chapman that he rides SR and Ruby Footpad.

Bromley earlier in the season -

Anthony Bromley, racing manager for owners Simon Munir and Isaac Souede said: “It was lovely to see. It wasn’t a total surprise as the horse has got great form over hurdles and he was always going to be a nice chaser. The manner of it was great.”

He went on: “It will be up to Willie (where he goes), but I imagine he will be campaigned between two and two and a half miles and then see where we go. It will fit around with what else he has got.

“I was pleased Daryl (Jacob, retained rider) got the chance to ride him as he rode him in most races last season as he was always the second or third string in the Grade Ones in the Mullins yard. When Ruby (Walsh) had a sore hand, it was nice Daryl could go and ride him.

“Whether he will get back on him is another thing as I imagine he will be first choice in that division now.

This is a very interesting line for me, given they have SR who hasn't looked anything other than a 2m horse booked for a run in the Arkle, if they work around that then potentially could end up JLT after all!

I would say that it highly unlikely at this stage however, but IF that was taken literally then I'd guess both horses would be split up.

Edit: Maybe I should read the b****y quote properly actually, he means what Willie has and not what the owners have! :very_drunk:
 
Not sure if this has been mentioned but Brain Power has had a wind op since his last run/fall.

Henderson said: "He worked this morning and I was very pleased. He has had his wind op - he will have these great initials (in the racecard) after his name when he appears.

"He is a little bit forgotten, but nothing has gone right. He won very nicely the first time. We did not want to make the running at Sandown the next time and that was a bit of a disaster.

"We then went to Ascot, not to say we were going to beat Un De Sceaux, but what I wanted was a real good gallop. Everything was going great until he turned out of Swinley Bottom to come up the hill and he just choked and that was his palate.

"He is a very talented horse. It is a hot Arkle and they are going to go a good gallop. It's open and I think Footpad has looked very good and Saint Calvados has looked very good. ;)

"Brain Power was the best of them over hurdles by a quite long way and is a very good jumper of fences."

----- Not sure I agree with Nicky's last statement though!!!
 
Hi there, long time lurker, first time poster. You all seem a friendly (and very knowledgable) bunch. Heading to my 5th festival in a row - all 4 days again.

I thought I'd finally post on this thread.

I really do feel Brain Power is the forgotten horse here. I think he's comfortably the best English horse on GS or better. Not to say he'll win, but I think he's being forgotten.

I know someone (not closely at all, I should add, but who gave me very solid intel on how much the Hendo camp truly knew Altior would beat Min), who said (albeit a year ago now), that the Hendo camp really do rate BP a lot.

I think posters before me have quoted Hendo taking about how BP's who's the only one in the stable who can keep with Altior on the gallops. But I also recall D Mullins talking him massively up after his first chase run.

Since then he's had excuses: a very tactical race with SR, where he unseated, likely beaten, but where Mullins gave him an awful ride. Hendo came out and said as much. The plan was never to lead them around...Mullins has been ditched since then for NdB (who has the best "close finish" record of all the top jockeys, I believe).

Thereafter he was pitched into open company against UdS, on unfavourable ground...and he was probably going to finish 4 lengths in 2nd had he not fallen at the last. No one else in this race has taken on anything as strong as UdS over fences. To me that form reads very well for the Arkle.

He's then has a wind op, whilst his owner, Buckley, continues to speak bullishly.

Footpad has clearly been very impressive. Willie loves him and he'll probably win. But BP is surely a fantastic ew bet. The prices offered stand out to me as a being extremely generous.

My only real concern is Cheltenham as a course, as he has a poor record there. But people seem to have forgotten he faded so quickly two out last year in the CH because he lost a shoe (as well as probably doing a bit too much racing early on).

I know these sound like lots of excuses, but I think most stack up, and the yard have so much belief in him. 12-16s seen madness to me.
 
Apologies for any typos; I'm on my phone and predicative txt occasionally let's me down.
 
Welcome TCH. GOod first post, lots of very interesting and well thought out points.

My only "niggle" about the amount of faith they have, is for every example we could find where they are right (Altior) ... I could find one that was wrong (Charli Parcs)?

Persoanlly in a lucky spot to have Brain Power e/w at 20/1 which does eliminate my need to be quite so effusive one way or the other and sometimes it is hard to take a fresh look on a race.

If I was starting now though, with no bet in the race.... would 16/1 for Brain Power compensate all of the concerns/excuses/points you've mentioned? His prep/fall last time, the track, beaten by SR, a wind op(positive?), bullish comments(positive?).

Prior to the Kingmaker I'd have had North Hill Harvey as the best each way bet back at Cheltenham but that looks to be wrong. He;s now 25s from 16s what I thought that.

I think you can certainly make a case that Saint Calvados and Sceau Royal are too short... which could perhaps but him 3rd in the betting, but Footpad and Petit Mouchoir set the standard AND are closely matched for me.... so you'd have to be hoping Brain Power not only usurped the two British rivals, but also hope the British form is stronger than the Irish? I feel the each way value is a little squeezed

All very well me saying that, but what would I back each way now? Well I'd really struggle, because I think whichever horse is "best of the British" may still end up 3rd at best?
 
Apologies for any typos; I'm on my phone and predicative txt occasionally let's me down.

I thought 16s was big too & already have a little on each way. Whilst it has happened yet, so clearly comes with a health warning, if he put it all together he’s certainly got the engine to go well - at 16s I’m happy to take the punt in a race which will likely have relatively few runners. The last 2 years I was on Vaniteux & Charbel at 33s & 25s with big profits on both for a top 3 finish - so due a change of luck!
 
I have calculated the sectionals of all 4 races featuring Footpad & Petit Mouchair, my findings are below.

Ryanair hurdle: PM is 1.98seconds quicker than FP from first to post and 9.42 seconds quicker than the 2m4f handicap the winner of which was mid 120s and carried 7lb less. Looking at his sectionals versus the handicap, it shows he tends to go hard at the start of a race, gradually reducing speed as the race unfolds, before a drop in pace, then kick for home but he is doing his work early in his races. Footpad was never really a factor in this race.

Irish Champion hurdle: PM tries similar tactics to the Ryanair hurdle, on the clock FP is well able to match him for pace and actually runs from first to post 0.96 seconds quicker the PM. PM has a nice lead built up at the first and FPs hold up tactics prove costly going down by about 1L. Footpad is about 5.75L quicker from the 2nd last to the winning post than PM. Incredibly this race is run 20second quicker than Christmas with the going having good in the description. However, comparing the time to that of Let's Dance in the grade 2 shows the race was not the all out gallop it could have been. Let's Dance is 0.11 seconds quicker than PM from first to last and you wouldn't say she is all out in the race although she is well ridden out and in receipt of 14lb.

Champion Hurdle: Again FP is quicker first to last than PM this time by .56seconds and his hold up tactics proving costly again. Labaik was 1.06 seconds faster than PM first to post. Similar tactics used by PM again although he didn't go as hard early this time.

Hurdle races overall: Discounting the first race as FP was non-competitive, its is interesting to note that each race has 8 hurdles, in the Irish Champion, FP is nearly 5L quicker than PM between the 5th and 8th but only 0.01 second between the last and post. In the Champion Hurdle it is a similar story, FP is 3L quicker between the 5th and 8th but 0.15 slower from last to post. This really makes me question the tactics used on FP, while he can generally match the early pace that PM goes he is doing his toughest work to get into contention before the finish, therefore not leaving as much in the tank for the actual finish, a more positive ride closer to the pace would make sense.

Irish Arkle: Footpad again quicker from first to post, this time 0.8 seconds but is eased before the line. The race also compares quite favourably with the handicap chase over the same distance in which Patrick's Park was 1.3 seconds slower and all out unlike Footpad, but also carrying 26lb less. From 1st to 9th PP was approx 16.5L behind FP but about 11L quicker from 2 out. PP was all out and FP was eased so you can probably knock the bulk of that off in what was a very impressive performance.

Overall, my doubts on FP have eased considerably and I think a positive ride from the off will see him win this.
 
Last edited:
I have calculated the sectionals of all 4 races featuring Footpad & Petit Mouchair, my findings are below.

Ryanair hurdle: PM is 1.98seconds quicker than FP from first to post and 9.42 seconds quicker than the 2m4f handicap the winner of which was mid 120s and carried 7lb less. Looking at his sectionals versus the handicap, it shows he tends to go hard at the start of a race, gradually reducing speed as the race unfolds, before a drop in pace, then kick for home but he is doing his work early in his races. Footpad was never really a factor in this race.

Irish Champion hurdle: PM tries similar tactics to the Ryanair hurdle, on the clock FP is well able to match him for pace and actually runs from first to post 0.96 seconds quicker the PM. PM has a nice lead built up at the first and FPs hold up tactics prove costly going down by about 1L. Footpad is about 5.75L quicker from the 2nd last to the winning post than PM. Incredibly this race is run 20second quicker than Christmas with the going having good in the description. However, comparing the time to that of Let's Dance in the grade 2 shows the race was not the all out gallop it could have been. Let's Dance is 0.11 seconds quicker than PM from first to last and you wouldn't say she is all out in the race although she is well ridden out and in receipt of 14lb.

Champion Hurdle: Again FP is quicker first to last than PM this time by .56seconds and his hold up tactics proving costly again. Labaik was 1.06 seconds faster than PM first to post. Similar tactics used by PM again although he didn't go as hard early this time.

Hurdle races overall: Discounting the first race as FP was non-competitive, its is interesting to note that each race has 8 hurdles, in the Irish Champion, FP is nearly 5L quicker than PM between the 5th and 8th but only 0.01 second between the last and post. In the Champion Hurdle it is a similar story, FP is 3L quicker between the 5th and 8th but 0.15 slower from last to post. This really makes me question the tactics used on FP, while he can generally match the early pace that PM goes he is doing his toughest work to get into contention before the finish, therefore not leaving as much in the tank for the actual finish, a more positive ride closer to the pace would make sense.

Irish Arkle: Footpad again quicker from first to post, this time 0.8 seconds but is eased before the line. The race also compares quite favourably with the handicap chase over the same distance in which Patrick's Park was 1.3 seconds slower and all out unlike Footpad, but also carrying 26lb less. From 1st to 9th PP was approx 16.5L behind FP but about 11L quicker from 2 out. PP was all out and FP was eased so you can probably knock the bulk of that off in what was a very impressive performance.

Overall, my doubts on FP have eased considerably and I think a positive ride from the off will see him win this.

And that's the reason I grind slots to pay for my summer holidays, and not horses.

Incredible amount of work must have gone into that, Folski.

giphy.gif