• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

2024 Champion Hurdle (Previously Constitution Hill thread)

There seems to be a modern kind of snobery around hurdling, C Hill could go on to win 3 or 4 champion hurdles and be lauded the greatest hurdler of all time but for many it won't be enough because he didn't add G1 chases to his CV, chase championships seem (in the modern world) to have greater value than hurdling championships for some reason.
He's a special horse and one that could go unbeaten for five years, personally I think it should be celebrated whatever he achieves, but I don't have a financial position on him...
 
For me it's not about financial position. I want him to be the best ever. The sport needs dreams like that to become reality. For me, if he can jump a fence well, he has as much chance winning a GC than winning 3 more Champion Hurdles. IMO I think he has a greater chance. Hard enough to stay sound for 3 years and retain his form/speed let alone be the best 2m hurdler out there. If he won the next 2 say, is he likely to be considered the best Hurdler ever ? What, beating State Man 2 more times, unlikely. Win a Supreme, Champion Hurdle, Arkle and Gold Cup by 2025.......yes, I'd consider him the best ever. Would bore me to tears were he to stay Hurdling. Of course, if they school him and he's shit then they only have one option but if they school him and he's electric then please do the right thing. Go for glory , be brave, go down in history.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glasgow Ronnie
So much could go wrong with going chasing, with the aim of running in the gold cup

CH may not stay
CH could get injuried or fail to recover from a GC to come back the next year

instead, stay over hurdles and have a campaign which will mitigate some risk

stick with hurdles and dominate for the next 2-3 seasons

A tad boring for some, but 2-3 champion hurdles isn’t to be sniffed at. Could take him over to Ireland aswell and pick up some good wins - but too much talk and not enough action
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf
For me it's not about financial position. I want him to be the best ever. The sport needs dreams like that to become reality. For me, if he can jump a fence well, he has as much chance winning a GC than winning 3 more Champion Hurdles. IMO I think he has a greater chance. Hard enough to stay sound for 3 years and retain his form/speed let alone be the best 2m hurdler out there. If he won the next 2 say, is he likely to be considered the best Hurdler ever ? What, beating State Man 2 more times, unlikely. Win a Supreme, Champion Hurdle, Arkle and Gold Cup by 2025.......yes, I'd consider him the best ever. Would bore me to tears were he to stay Hurdling. Of course, if they school him and he's shit then they only have one option but if they school him and he's electric then please do the right thing. Go for glory , be brave, go down in history.

Best Man gets ridiculed for winning three Gold Cups, people crab the horses he beat, to some
he needed to win a National or Irish National to be considered a great.
Sometimes connections just can’t win.
I’d have thought hanging around and winning three Champion Hurdles would be an exceptional
feat, equalled only by a few elite hurdlers in history, win four and he goes down as being as good as my
namesake who was cruely denied a fourth by foot and mouth !
And I don’t recall there being a clamour for Istabraq to go chasing, it was the 90s though and that was a hazy decade…
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carnage at Taunton
Just as much risk Hurdling as there is Chasing. Especially at the top. That's been done to death before on here.
Reading your post just confirms to me how boring it would be if he stays Hurdling. We'd probably only see him twice a year before the festival every season as well and not again after. A waste of a supreme talent. Don't do it to the horse.

That's me done. Not another word on it. Makes me sad.
 
......Fat Jockey Forum pages :highly_amused: :triumphant:




and yes HesTheOne - very much could, and he's earned the right to flap his gums too.

More interesting than reading people's opinion on whether Kane should move to Bayern to win trophies or stay and break Shearer's record - wasted far too long reading that stuff today.

:highly_amused::applouse:
 
Just as much risk Hurdling as there is Chasing. Especially at the top. That's been done to death before on here.
Reading your post just confirms to me how boring it would be if he stays Hurdling. We'd probably only see him twice a year before the festival every season as well and not again after. A waste of a supreme talent. Don't do it to the horse.

That's me done. Not another word on it. Makes me sad.

Interesting view that Lobos, winning 3 or 4 Champion Hurdles being a waste of a talent...
 
Some of my favourite horses never jumped a fence. It'd be nice to see them be really ambitious and win the lot. But winning a bunch of Champion Hurdles would also be awesome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carnage at Taunton
Interesting view that Lobos, winning 3 or 4 Champion Hurdles being a waste of a talent...

If he got new challengers each season then I'd think it was great, especially if they were UK based.
Unfortunately I fear we'll have to wait for one race a season to have any real doubts (still odds on doubts) barring accidents of course.
Hopefully this is a bare minimum and the Irish keep throwing different challengers at him.
If it ends up as State Man vs CH every year then that will be pretty sad.

Like watching Heavyweight boxing at the minute, now that is a fucking joke.

I do think they may be a little narrow minded in their vision and what the horse could achieve though.
He could easily run in three novice chases during the season and win three grade 1 hurdles as well.

The horse looks like he makes all the decisions and posh boy is there for the ride, so switching disciplines looks easy for this lad.
As in he doesn't look the type to hurdle fences and jump high over hurdles.

They won't do that though, of course.
The frustrating part of the recent bulletins is the sudden emergence of the doubtful stayer excuse/reason.

When they do confirm hurdling though they will be more forthcoming and admit it's the safer option and an attractive thought to be a multiple winner of the Champion Hurdle, as well as collecting weak grade ones as practice before the big day. Nothing wrong with that, just probably could have not dragged it out as long.

More of a saga than when we debated on here which novice hurdle race "Birchdale" was going to run in. Approximately 30 pages of it.
That's when I started self harming and grinding my teeth.:numbness:
I blame COD :highly_amused:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf
If he got new challengers each season then I'd think it was great, especially if they were UK based.
Unfortunately I fear we'll have to wait for one race a season to have any real doubts (still odds on doubts) barring accidents of course.
Hopefully this is a bare minimum and the Irish keep throwing different challengers at him.
If it ends up as State Man vs CH every year then that will be pretty sad.

I think that's a view shared by plenty Quevega, personally I think it might be a little disrespectful to State Man who has a bunch of G1 wins to his name.
I remember the likes of Hurricane Fly winning 3 runner races at 5s on before winning champion hurdles, I know it's a cliche but the horse can only beat what's put in front of them.
Arkle suffered similarly, scared everyone off, didn't they even change the handicap system to try getting him beat ?
I can't imagine it was overly exciting watching him win a Gold Cup by 30l at 10s on but that doesn't change how talented the horse was.

I get the arguments against him swerving a chase career, but I am unsure why there's a perception that jumping fences is more credible than jumping timber...
 
I can only speak for myself and rate both disciplines the same.
But If a horse could be a champion in both during his career then they would probably rank above "specialists" IMO.
 
Just as much risk Hurdling as there is Chasing. Especially at the top. That's been done to death before on here.
Reading your post just confirms to me how boring it would be if he stays Hurdling. We'd probably only see him twice a year before the festival every season as well and not again after. A waste of a supreme talent. Don't do it to the horse.

That's me done. Not another word on it. Makes me sad.

Sorry Lobos, I love your passion for this forum and respect your opinion, but I would have to totally disagree here. The risks of jumping a fence compared to a hurdle are much, much greater. I could write loads here honestly.

Just think if the Grand National was run over hurdles. Do you think 15 horses would fall every year and another 10 get pulled up?

Its really not even a discussion, in my humble opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Exar Essay
Sorry Lobos, I love your passion for this forum and respect your opinion, but I would have to totally disagree here. The risks of jumping a fence compared to a hurdle are much, much greater. I could write loads here honestly.

Just think if the Grand National was run over hurdles. Do you think 15 horses would fall every year and another 10 get pulled up?

Its really not even a discussion, in my humble opinion.

And you have to jump around 50% more obstacles in a 2M Chase than in a 2M hurdle. (12 vs 8 on a lot of courses)
 
I posted stats from Cheltenham races over a long period when we had this discussion before which showed there was very little difference in deaths of horses at the course in Hurdle races compared to Chase . Believe it or not, more are lost in their fields/training facilities than at the racecourse.
 
I posted stats from Cheltenham races over a long period when we had this discussion before which showed there was very little difference in deaths of horses at the course in Hurdle races compared to Chase . Believe it or not, more are lost in their fields/training facilities than at the racecourse.

We’re injuries covered in that piece or just deaths only?
 
We’re injuries covered in that piece or just deaths only?

Just deaths. Clearly keeping tabs with all injuries would be an impossible task.

Travelling quicker over Hurdles was a leveller
 
I posted stats from Cheltenham races over a long period when we had this discussion before which showed there was very little difference in deaths of horses at the course in Hurdle races compared to Chase . Believe it or not, more are lost in their fields/training facilities than at the racecourse.

It’s nothing to do with deaths.

How many horses fall over a fence as a ‘hurdle’??

How many horses fall over a hurdle as a ‘hurdle’??

And even more importantly, how many horses plough through a hurdle and continue through the race as though nothing’s happened???????
 
It’s nothing to do with deaths.

How many horses fall over a fence as a ‘hurdle’??

How many horses fall over a hurdle as a ‘hurdle’??

And even more importantly, how many horses plough through a hurdle and continue through the race as though nothing’s happened???????

And due to those falls are
● injured,
● unable to race for long periods,
● never as good when they return from injury, or
● retired due to injury
 
  • Like
Reactions: Star De Mohaison