Captain Chris
Member
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2020
- Messages
- 436
- Reaction score
- 190
- Points
- 43
Without seeing the whole report and a proposed fixture list, it's difficult to judge it. Agree with both points above though. Far reduced fixture list would be the first port of call. Although it needs to be properly thought out. For example, I'm all for converting the Clarence House to a handicap, but if you leave the Desert Orchid and Game Spirit as they are, then it will just get ignored (from a grade 1 horse perspective).
I'd like to see the penalty structure for conditions races revamped. Eg. For a grade 2,let's say the Desert Orchid. Something along the lines of a starting weight of 10-6, 3lb penalty for every grade 3 win in the last 2 years, 7lb for every grade 2 win and 10lb for every grade 1 win, up to a maximum weight of 11-12. Half penalties for novice races maybe. Essentially creating a limited handicap and guiding grade 1 horses elsewhere towards the programme that they are intended to use.
Rather than receiving weight, Shishkin would have carried 11-9 (17lb penalty for 2xG1 and 2xG2 novice wins)
Greaneteen 11-12 (2xG1 + G2)
Sky Pirate 10-9 (G3)
Before Midnight 10-6
Seeing Shishkin give a stone and a beating to a 157 rated horse would have got me far more excited (and probably made the handicapper recalibrate Sky Pirate's mark) as well as encouraging more horses to take him on in receipt of the weight.
I'd like to see the penalty structure for conditions races revamped. Eg. For a grade 2,let's say the Desert Orchid. Something along the lines of a starting weight of 10-6, 3lb penalty for every grade 3 win in the last 2 years, 7lb for every grade 2 win and 10lb for every grade 1 win, up to a maximum weight of 11-12. Half penalties for novice races maybe. Essentially creating a limited handicap and guiding grade 1 horses elsewhere towards the programme that they are intended to use.
Rather than receiving weight, Shishkin would have carried 11-9 (17lb penalty for 2xG1 and 2xG2 novice wins)
Greaneteen 11-12 (2xG1 + G2)
Sky Pirate 10-9 (G3)
Before Midnight 10-6
Seeing Shishkin give a stone and a beating to a 157 rated horse would have got me far more excited (and probably made the handicapper recalibrate Sky Pirate's mark) as well as encouraging more horses to take him on in receipt of the weight.