I think the notion that this is some Kangaroo Court that has a predefined outcome is a bit off. Yes the solicitors acting for both sides will have met and discussed the case before hand, but this ruling has to stand up to precedent and appeal and will be deliberated and decided with full legal rigor.
It can then be appealed to a Civil Court or Court of Arbitration for Sport - the chances of this happening are slim, but if the punishment is unduly harsh then no reason that he cannot, and if during these hearings it transpired that there was some behind closed doors deal done before the hearing then the reputational damage would be far beyond anything Gordon has done.
Some interesting extracts from the Byrnes case and appeal, and the link below if anyone is at a loose end!!
Appears the max fine they can impose is 20k
Ban takes effect 14 days after the hearing
Rule 19C confers a wide range of particular powers on the Appeals Body in addition to and not in substitution for any power conferred by any other Rule. T
hese include the power to suspend licences of trainers and to impose fines not exceeding €20,000. In particular the Rule confers a broad power on the Appeals Body
“to increase decrease or waive any penalty that may have been imposed by………. the Referrals Committee…..” The Referrals Committee referred in its decision to a case in which the Appeals Body considered the penalty of a fine to be unduly lenient: it replaced it with the suspension of the trainer’s licence.
At the same time, the Appeals Body proceeds, as it must, on the basis that no charge has been brought against Mr Byrnes of being involved either in the doping or the betting activity.
Such a charge would have entailed “acts….prejudicial to the integrity, proper conduct or good reputation of horseracing…” contrary to Rule 272 or breaches of Rule 96.
Any such charges would be at a different level of seriousness
The Referrals Committee found the
“actual and potential consequences of the failure to supervise [the horse]..disturbing.” The
“gelding was a danger to all nearby persons and animals.” Any person betting on
Viking Hoard was dishonestly deprived a fair run for his money. The Committee considered that Mr Byrnes had indulged in an
“unacceptable level of risk-taking..” It felt that a “purely financial sanction on the trainer would be insufficient and inappropriate on the facts of the case.”
Whilst the Appeals Body accepts that there is no evidence that he was aware of the extraordinary and suspicious betting activity on Viking Hoard, it simply cannot ignore the very serious consequences which flowed from his misconduct and dereliction of duty as follows:
- the very real and significant risk posed to the health, safety and welfare of the horse, jockey and indeed all participants in the race,
- the financial loss to the affected punters, and
- the consequential reputational damage to the integrity of the racing industry.
For these reasons, the Appeals Body reaffirms the decision on penalty of the Referrals Committee to order the withdrawal of Mr Byrnes’ licence for the period of six months as well as the fine of €1,000.
It holds that the six-month period of time of the withdrawal of licence will, in substitution for the decision of the Referrals Committee made pursuant to Rule 19A, take effect fourteen days from the date of this decision of the Appeals Body.
https://www.ihrb.ie/referrals-appea...ed-substance-appeal-tramore-18th-october-2018