• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

General Chat

Have seen some stuff on Twitter in support of racing which I think is a great idea to whoever started it!

#fortheloveofhorses

Everyone within racing posting using this, will help a great deal at this time imo.
 
Statement from the IRTA seems pretty well balanced IMO
 

Attachments

  • 022DD3F9-00B6-4674-AD5D-C342237E05BE.jpeg
    022DD3F9-00B6-4674-AD5D-C342237E05BE.jpeg
    62.7 KB · Views: 0
A very good point. I also saw a very good synopsis in this thread about how some people defer to comedy to make the best of a bad situation, this is also a very Irish trait. Apologies in advance if this gets a little dark but it needs to be highlighted.

For full disclosure, I was born and raised in rural Ireland with a strong farming background, with horses and all sorts of farm animals. Death is part of the occupation, you become desensitized to it, you almost have to if you wish to remain in the trade. Do not get me wrong, what Elliot and others have done is incredibly stupid and it does no positive to the game of racing. But in the grand scheme of things, it should not be a hanging offense! When you are the carer of 300+ horses, its impossible to have emotional attachment to them all. Sitting on a dead animal while grinning at the camera is idiotic and is not a good look, but for some context, what do people think happens to the horse as part of next steps in disposing the body? There are no animal grave yards. That horse would have been picked up by its hind legs and loaded into the back of a truck to the local knackery. There the carcass would be skinned and disemboweled before being chopped up and on tomorrows menu at the local hunt kennels or Dublin Zoo. Having someone sitting on the horse is disrespectful however the disposal of the horse isn't?

I have friends who teach kids in urban areas and the disconnect between animals and human is amazing if they are anything to go by. Some were shocked to learn where milk on their shop shelves actually comes from for example, never mind when the conversation is raised of where their meat is coming from.

Unfortunately racing will pander to people who are so far removed from the realities of animal ownership and livelihoods that revolve around animals. They will recline on their leather chairs after their lamb dinners, happy in the knowledge that something they were told is cruel is being knocked down a peg or two.

It's a momentary lack of judgement that shows a distinct lack of class - Elliott should be punished accordingly. Owners moving their horses away is the worst punishment he will face and rightly so

Super stuff PP
 
  • Like
Reactions: PresentingPercy
On a different topic. Well as a newbie I didn't want to get involved in a flaming row but I can't help thinking that the festival tipping competition encourages picking favourites in all the races since it awards points for 1234 as well as "bonus" points for a the SP for a winner.

To simplify consider a win only competition with 10 points for a win plus the SP. And consider two horses in a race. One is the even money favourite and one is at 9/1. Run the race 10 times (or 10 different races with the same pair of odds). Betting odds mean something. They come from the collective wisdom of punters plus input from the bookies and stable whispers etc leading to market moves.

So on average you would expect the evens favourite to win 5 of those 10 races: total score = 60 (or 55 if you discount the stake return)
On average you expect the 9/1 shot to win just once: total score = 20 (or 19 if you discount the stake return)

On the other hand if you just score based on what you would receive back from the bookie for a ?1 level stake, then in each case you score 10 points.

For the competition as described choosing each favourite would have yielded 144.7 points in 2020 if my adding is correct. I divided the returns for two joint favourites by two.
How would that have done last year?

P.S. I didn't put this in the tipping thread so as not to disturb the flow of actual selections.
 
Last edited:
On a different topic. Well as a newbie I didn't want to get involved in a flaming row but I can't help thinking that the festival tipping competition encourages picking favourites in all the races since it awards points for 1234 as well as "bonus" points for a the SP for a winner.

Suggestions always welcomed but I
actually think the reverse is true and by awarding the SP equivalent in points for a winner shows this.
The festival always throws up surprise winners at big prices, if someone was clever enough to find one of these 33/1 shots others would need three even money shot winners to have comparable points and last year proved how vulnerable the shorties always are.

ryanh97 any thoughts ?
 
What do we think the Morans will do with Zanahiyr and co?

Hearing the bosses Oscar gone Noel Meade :boxing: hopefully whatever they do will be a temporary thing for Cheltenham with Gordon still pulling the strings so to speak. I like Noel Meade don’t get me wrong but he wouldn’t be one id be trusting to get ready for a big one these days.
 
Suggestions always welcomed but I
actually think the reverse is true and by awarding the SP equivalent in points for a winner shows this.
The festival always throws up surprise winners at big prices, if someone was clever enough to find one of these 33/1 shots others would need three even money shot winners to have comparable points and last year proved how vulnerable the shorties always are.

ryanh97 any thoughts ?

I agree with you Ista but I'm definitely happy to consider Supermaster's suggestions. I'll leave it the way it is this year and then I'll put put a thread over the summer for people's opinions on improvements. It'll help to generate a bit of conversation over those dark summer months
 
  • Like
Reactions: Supermaster
But can you not see how that would piss Irish folk off, given it’s not even their area of jurisdiction, and the Irish authorities enquiry is still ongoing? It’s an absolutely gross overstep, IMO, and has put a lot of people’s backs up.

He’s admitted it!! So what are they truly going to get out of an enquiry 5 days after the event?
 
He’s admitted it!! So what are they truly going to get out of an enquiry 5 days after the event?

Not wanting to drag this on, but since you directly replied to me - I’d imagine they have to select a panel for the hearing, consult legal counsel, review the regulations & previous cases/precedents to see what would be deemed a fair & reasonable punishment, take statements from Gordon & anybody else that was there, take character references and the like from people with knowledge of the yard to see if it was a one of or part of a pattern.

I don’t think 4 days is unreasonable to arrange for a fair & thorough enquiry. It’s not as simple as he’s sat on a horse - hang the bastard.

Think this will continue to be a bit divisive & I’m going to try to not comment further unless I think there’s really something tangible I can add.
 
Hearing the bosses Oscar gone Noel Meade :boxing: hopefully whatever they do will be a temporary thing for Cheltenham with Gordon still pulling the strings so to speak. I like Noel Meade don’t get me wrong but he wouldn’t be one id be trusting to get ready for a big one these days.

Really?! Bloody hell. That's not the news I was hoping for.

Surprised as thought the Morans would stick with him.
 
Really?! Bloody hell. That's not the news I was hoping for.

Surprised as thought the Morans would stick with him.

It’s just a rumour so take it with a pinch of salt but I’ve heard morans to Noel Meade, that’s all I’ve heard and I’d expect (hope) it’s just a contingency for Cheltenham so they’re under his name on the race card. Morans are tied in pretty deep with Gordon and are actually a sponsor of his, I’d be very surprised if they didn’t stick by him in the medium & long term.
 
All these owners can transfer them back as quickly as they transfer them out can't they ??
 
It’s just a rumour so take it with a pinch of salt but I’ve heard morans to Noel Meade, that’s all I’ve heard and I’d expect (hope) it’s just a contingency for Cheltenham so they’re under his name on the race card. Morans are tied in pretty deep with Gordon and are actually a sponsor of his, I’d be very surprised if they didn’t stick by him in the medium & long term.

Yes exactly. I know they are close. Would seem odd if they are sticking by him to have made that decision so quickly though. Sure Gordon will be doing whatever he can to make sure his Cheltenham runners travel, even if it means having Busty's name over the door. His stepping back for the short term is likely the only way he will have anything to come back to.
 
I feel genuinely sorry for the stable staff at Gordon's. Imagine looking after a horse like Envoi Allen, taking care of him every day, building up to the festival and looking forward to a bright future, for it all to be taken away. Must be tough on them

I follow the girl who looks after envoi on twitter. Almost every post is her doting on him. Refers to him as ‘my world’. Can’t imagine how she’s feeling right now. Awful for her.
 
Suggestions always welcomed but I
actually think the reverse is true and by awarding the SP equivalent in points for a winner shows this.
The festival always throws up surprise winners at big prices, if someone was clever enough to find one of these 33/1 shots others would need three even money shot winners to have comparable points and last year proved how vulnerable the shorties always are.

ryanh97 any thoughts ?

Well you could nominate a price like 33/1 and pick horses at that price. You don't know what price a long price winner will be beforehand. That wouldn't have done too well in 2020. Or look at how picking the 2nd/3rd/4th favourite etc would have done. I don't intend to do that as I don't think I need to to make the point, The 2020 results are just one example but the basic principle is shown by the simplified example I used.
 
Why not hang fire a few days if you are planning on keeping them there?

Yep. Plenty of time yet. I'd imagine all the prep work is done and the travelling is booked up already so no rush.
 
Davy explained the circumstances and it was accepted he acted out of safety, not cruelty, regardless of how bad it looked, hence only the 4 day ban. The horse was playing up and he gave it a knock to the back of the head to try and get his mind back on the task at hand, which is in the horses interest from a safety point of view. Lots of people will tell you corrective behaviour is a basic part of horsemanship (as other Jockey's like RJ did at the time), and when you consider the physiological implications of horses falling at 35mph, a tap to the back of the head does absolutely nothing - so basically, have a go at Gordon all you want because he deserves it, but please don't drag Davy into this debate with flippant comments like that cause they're just unnecessary. He was punished, a line was drawn, we move on.

That’s undoubtedly the best post on this thread (I’ve just caught up with about 10 pages of it). Well said.