Announcement

Collapse

Fat Jockey Patrons

Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated.
Become a Patron!

You can also make a one-off donation here:
See more
See less

Ultima Handicap Chase 2019

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by doctorwu View Post
    Cant understand the interest in this horse? doesn't fit trends for this race.
    The interest? ...because the majority of successful punters don't follow blindly trends?

    Has a horse placed in a Gold Cup and that has won a 4 miler ever raced in this race? I wouldn't have thought so (Holywell closest?) and I wouldn't care either way.


    The interest shouldn't be hard to fathom?

    Comment


    • Originally posted by ComplyOrDie View Post
      It's not so much the Gold Cup place per se, more the festival form which is more crucial, I just name dropped the race as it is the blue ribbon of the festival
      It's not just you who've brought it up, few people using the GC run as a plus point for this. I'm guilty of it somewhat myself, having backed Kilultagh Vic for the Coral Cup with a run in the GC and a previous festival win.

      Comment


      • Originally posted by Kevloaf View Post
        The interest? ...because the majority of successful punters don't follow blindly trends?

        Has a horse placed in a Gold Cup and that has won a 4 miler ever raced in this race? I wouldn't have thought so (Holywell closest?) and I wouldn't care either way.


        The interest shouldn't be hard to fathom?
        Its not just trends, you basically need an improving horse for this race.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by luisgarciaisgod View Post
          sorry I'll rephrase that, who was the last horse to be placed in a Gold Cup to come back and win a different race at the festival, preferably a handicap since plenty using this as an angle regarding MR
          Almost impossible.
          You run well in a Gold Cup your rating will be so high you are unlikely to drop to a level you can win a festival handicap and the only half suitable handicap would be the Ultima.
          Small chance a chaser may revert back to hurdles and benefit from a lower mark but I can't recall this ever being done...

          Comment


          • Originally posted by doctorwu View Post
            COD,
            You need a horse showing signs of improvement for this race. 22s is only value if he delivers.........I can't have him at all.
            All the best with him.
            Would you have had Holywell and UTPT as improvers when they won it on the second occasion?

            Comment


            • Originally posted by doctorwu View Post
              Its not just trends, you basically need an improving horse for this race.
              You need an improving horse?
              yet another trend is:
              Best rating over 3m.

              Can a step up in trip not bring out improvement?



              A 100% trends based approach to any race is flawed IMHO. A broken clock is right twice a day though, so let's hope some of our selections align

              Comment


              • Originally posted by Faugheen_Machine View Post
                Would you have had Holywell and UTPT as improvers when they won it on the second occasion?
                Anyone remember Beuna Vista ?
                Runner up in Pertemps first year, won second year, third attempt at the race at aged 10 he came there tanking won 4l and was being pulled up 50 yards from the line.
                Ridiculous performance....

                Not that it has anything to do with the Ultima !

                Comment


                • Originally posted by Kevloaf View Post
                  You need an improving horse?
                  yet another trend is:
                  Best rating over 3m.

                  Can a step up in trip not bring out improvement?



                  A 100% trends based approach to any race is flawed IMHO. A broken clock is right twice a day though, so let's hope some of our selections align
                  Hardly a good analogy Kev.
                  The best RPR over 3m is flawless so far, so I'll be sticking to it.
                  lets visit this again after the race.
                  Someone will be having a slice of humble pie.

                  Comment


                  • I have absolutely no doubt some of the races will go the way the trends say. But they are not the holy grail. I followed them religiously for a long time, including my first year as a poster on here. I've done better using them as a guide rather than factual evidence, because, as quite a few people have said, not just on here, but some of these previews too, you can get trends to fit a potential horse/bet, it's called confirmation bias.

                    I weigh some trends heavier than others, race dependant of course.

                    Now I'm not, and have never said Minella Rocco is the plot of the festival, but he ticks plenty for me at a price I'm happy with. In these races I usually end up 3 or 4 handed, also have CSS @ 33's, plus a couple of others, one of which is a likely non runner.
                    Last edited by ComplyOrDie; 28 February 2019, 05:12 PM.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by ComplyOrDie View Post
                      I have absolutely no doubt some of the races will go the way the trends say. But they are not the holy grail. I followed them religiously for a long time, including my first year as a poster on here. I've done better using them as a guide rather than factual evidence, because, as quite a few people have said, not just on here, but some of these previews too, you can get trends to fit a potential horse/bet, it's called confirmation bias.

                      I weigh some trends heavier than others, race dependant of course.
                      I only use them as a guide COD. But I will take some of them literally. I also stay well clear of certain trainers at the festival. I don't back A.King novices etc.

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by doctorwu View Post
                        Its not just trends, you basically need an improving horse for this race.
                        Not true at all.

                        8 of the last 9 were horses on the perceived decline having achieved higher marks previously.With the average of the 8 having being 8.5lb higher at one stage. Jonjo's 2 winners had being 13lb & 15lb higher than their current mark. Minella will run 14lb below his peak mark of 166. 5 of 9 had won or placed in a grade 1 over 3m.

                        I think he hits an awful lot of trends.

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by doctorwu View Post
                          Hardly a good analogy Kev.
                          The best RPR over 3m is flawless so far, so I'll be sticking to it.
                          lets visit this again after the race.
                          Someone will be having a slice of humble pie.
                          Well Minella Rocco's best RPR is certainly over 3m so he's in the mix then?

                          Flawless.

                          Comment


                          • Race distance - 3 miles and about one furlong. Will be aged between 7 and 9 yrs. Will have run before at the Festival or will be 7 or 8 yrs and improving i.e. with a rising handicap rating. Winner’s handicap rating over 140. Will have recorded their best Racing Post Rating over at least 3 miles. This rating will be at least 143. Will have already won at least a Class 3 chase.

                            All winners this century had recorded their best RPR over at least 3 miles.

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Kevloaf View Post
                              Well Minella Rocco's best RPR is certainly over 3m so he's in the mix then?

                              Flawless.
                              There ya go. Job done.

                              Comment


                              • To go back to the post I first highlighted, where you couldn't understand why people liked this horse as he doesn't fit the trends..... these are the trends from Gaulstats...

                                Summary

                                Race distance - 3 miles and about one furlong.

                                Will be aged between 7 and 9 yrs.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Will have run before at the Festival or will be 7 or 8 yrs and improving i.e. with a rising handicap rating.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Winner’s handicap rating over 140.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Will have recorded their best Racing Post Rating over at least 3 miles.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                This rating will be at least 143. Will have already won at least a Class 3 chase. If a novice, will have won a hurdle worth at least £10k to the winner.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Has won over 3 miles or at least placed over 3 miles in two of last three runs.
                                Fail for Minella Rocco

                                Will have run between 3 and 12 times over fences in UK and/or Ireland.
                                Fail for Minella Rocco


                                Will have run at least twice this season.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Will have been 1st or 2nd sometime this season. 1st or 2nd in either of last two chase runs or at least 3rd last time.
                                Fail for Minella Rocco

                                Winners over 11st becoming a lot more frequent.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Any price. One of the top weights to be placed.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Wasn't unplaced in this years Betbright Chase. If wins this after running in this season's Newbury Hennessy back it in the Grand National. Has run in the last 45 days.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                P Nicholls N Henderson poor enough records. W Mullins yet to have a runner.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Watch for D Pipe, Tony Martin and Jonjo trained.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Wears some type of headgear.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                Irish trained don't win but get placed.
                                Tick for Minella Rocco

                                No F, R, B or U as last form entry. Not a claiming jockey. Half a furlong longer in distance from 2014
                                Tick for Minella Rocco





                                I almost wish I was a trends backer based on that! Jeez!
                                If he doesn't win... I'll blame the trends boys
                                Last edited by Kevloaf; 28 February 2019, 05:29 PM.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X