• HELP US - Become a Patron - Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated ... a small donation each month would be a huge contribution. Become a Patron!

Who is the best judge of a tipster?

Post 4 of 4


The Final FJ ‘Best judge of a tipster’ leaderboard
1st - Istabraq - +?87.14
2nd - Can’tCatchMe - +?67.11
3rd - Quevega - +?56.34

Kevloaf - +?39.56
Big Bucks - +?26.87
Spectre - +?8.06
Jorvik - +?7
..............................................
Diamond Geezer - -?2.27
TheKingPimm - -?10.46
Faugheen_Machine - -?12.83
Birds Nest - -?13.82
Imperial Commander - -?24.44
Captain Chris - -?29.86
RufusFlynn - -?38.22
Chaser1980 - -?45
ComplyOrDie - -?58.28
Al Boum Photo - -?66.75
Nortonscoin - -?67.83
Jonthehammer - -?69.34
Craigy14 - -?75.25
Jono - -?76.90
Ryanh97 - -?79.02
Joleg - -?84.83
Native River - -?90.42
Dandrew99 - -?107
Charlie - -?122



Overall... it’s Ista who is the best judge of a judge. Well done mate.

And overall the bookie (yours truly) finished up from the FJ Forum by ?782.44

Thanks to DG for letting this run alongside his great tipping competition. And thanks to everyone who got involved. It kept me distracted back in December when I wasn’t feeling too good. That in itself is a win. And now here we are two months later. How time flies. It has been an absolute pleasure folks. MOM (George).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf and Diamond Geezer
Middle_Of_March said:
Post 4 of 4
Overall... it’s Ista who is the best judge of a judge. Well done mate.
Click to expand...

I look forward to Kev amending my profile !

Thanks for running this MoM, all good fun to go alongside the comp which appeared to capture the entire forum,
Enjoy your virtual ?782 !
 
  • Like
Reactions: Middle_Of_March
Istabraq said:
I look forward to Kev amending my profile !

Thanks for running this MoM, all good fun to go alongside the comp which appeared to capture the entire forum,
Enjoy your virtual ?782 !
Click to expand...

I’m having my whole virtual funds on Benie at 5/2 for the mares Chase in the spirit of the forum
 
Istabraq said:
I look forward to Kev amending my profile !

Thanks for running this MoM, all good fun to go alongside the comp which appeared to capture the entire forum,
Enjoy your virtual ?782 !
Click to expand...

Well done mate :triumphant:

And thanks to Middle_Of_March for organising it :applause::encouragement:​​​​​​​
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Middle_Of_March
Well done Ista and all those up in profit.

Thanks Middle_Of_March for running, virtual drinks are on you when Benie des Good Ting wins :cheerful:​​​​​​​
 
  • Like
Reactions: Middle_Of_March
Middle_Of_March said:
Group A:
  • Scooby - 23/10
  • BigChaang - 7/2
  • Joleg - 9/2
  • Aaalowe9 - 9/2
  • The King Pimm - 11/2
  • Fatcatshat - 9/1



Gone for Scooby as a relatively short priced fav here. He’s proven on FJ and is a paid tipster so has to be installed as the clear market fav. Felt abit harsh putting Fatcatshat (definitely the best named poster on the site) as the outsider of the six here but as he’s a new poster with just 16 posts, and therefore unknown on the tipping front, it’s a big ask on debut, to outperform proven quality in Joleg, TheKingPimm, Aaalowe9 and BigChaang - let alone our market leader for Group A. Hence why on a betting format, he’s the outsider here but if course it’s all in good spirit with no offence intended to anyone. Good luck to all.




Gameweek 1 Heats:

Aaalowe9 v Scooby

BigChaang v Joleg

TheKingPimm v FatCatShat
Click to expand...
I know this was 5 years ago but I didn’t half have some fun doing this.

Have been thinking for a little while that I will bring it back in the winter with both a betting market (with betting heats, group odds and an outright market to bet on) and the actual comp itself in memory of Diamond Geezer. Would be done across let’s say 6 race days over 3 weeks and then a knockout schedule thereafter for the last 16, quarters, semis and final.

Watch this space.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Bucks, Kevloaf, Joleg and 2 others
Kevloaf said:
I've laughed loads reading through these comments. Might be my favourite thread ever.

I can't believe FM is outright fav :highly_amused: I'd have done my brains on scooby fav at 1.01 - like Good to Soft :eagerness:


Me being the same price as ryanh97 - I don't even recall seeing a tip from the IT nerd....? --- same price as the mighty Kevloaf? Yorkhill 66/1 a couple of weeks ago didn't live long in the memory?


Seriously though, 9/1 is a horror price for me when Scooby is 8/1. If anyone backs me you're fucking clueless. :barbershop_quartet_member:


Also, I'm going to waste so much time revieiwing this market it'll almost certaintly take away from my actual tipping efforts.

Fantastic, and huge credit to Diamond Geezer and Middle_Of_March as I can't recall anything creating such amazing engagement ever before.
Click to expand...
This has chuckled me too.

F**k it.. I will 100% be bringing both competitions back for between December and February. With the actual tipping comp to be starting on the New Years Day card at Cheltenham on January 1st.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf and somer1
Middle_Of_March said:
Post 3 of 4

Outright results:
Ryanh97 - ?20 win on Imperial Commander @ 7/2
ComplyOrDie - ?20 win on Quevega @ 9/2
Jono - ?20 win on Quevega @ 9/2
Jonthehammer - ?20 win on BigChaang @ 6/1
Joleg - ?20 win on BigChaang @ 6/1
Nortonscoin200 - ?20 win on OscarWhisky @ 10/1
Spectre - ?20 win on OscarWhisky @ 10/1
Faugheen_Machine - ?20 win on OscarWhisky @ 10/1
Native River - ?20 win on Nortonscoin200 @ 11/1
Birds Nest - ?20 win on Nortonscoin200 @ 11/1
Diamond Geezer - ?20 win on Taylorch1990 @ 12/1
Big Bucks - ?10 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 7/1 (1/3 odds, top 2)
Istabraq - ?10 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 7/1 (1/3 odds, top 2)
Craigy14 - ?10 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 7/1 (1/3 odds, top 2)
Charlie - ?10 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 7/1 (1/3 odds, top 2)
RufusFlynn - ?10 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 7/1 (1/3 odds, top 2)
Kevloaf - ?10 E/W on Oscar Whiskey @ 10/1 (1/3 odds, top 2)
Imperial Commander - ?10 win on Ryanh97 @ 3/1
Imperial Commander - ?10 win on Quevega @ 9/2
Captain Chris - ?10 win on BigChaang @ 6/1
Captain Chris - ?10 win on Salubrious Chin @ 7/1
Diamond Geezer - ?5 E/W on Captain Chris @ 50/1
Captain Chris - ?5 E/W on Bigfish @ 100/1
Big Bucks - ?3 E/W on Istabraq @ 16/1
Istabraq - ?3 E/W on Crolwey113 @ 28/1
Charlie - ?5 win on Kevloaf @ 9/1
Captain Chris - ?5 win on Ryanh97 @ 11/1
Craigy14 - ?5 win on Jono @ 12/1
Al Boum Photo - ?5 win on Joleg @ 14/1
ComplyOrDie - ?5 win on Quevega @ 14/1
Ryanh97 - ?5 win on Tiger Rolll @ 16/1
TheKingPimm - ?5 win on BigChaang @ 18/1
Spectre - ?5 win on Brital @ 20/1
Jono - ?5 win on Brital @ 20/1
Imperial Commander - ?5 win on Craigy14 @ 20/1
ComplyOrDie - ?5 win on Craigy14 @ 20/1
Diamond Geezer - ?5 win on Craigy14 @ 20/1
Nortonscoin200 - ?5 win on Quevega @ 22/1
Captain Chris - ?5 win on Quevega @ 22/1
Chaser1980 - ?5 win on Craigy14 @ 33/1
Joleg - ?5 win on OverTheLast @ 40/1
Istabraq - ?5 win on Salubrious Chin @ 40/1
Charlie - ?5 win on TheKingPimm @ 66/1
Birds Nest - ?5 win on TheKingPimm @ 66/1
Ryan97 - ?5 win on The KingPimm @ 66/1
Birds Nest - ?5 win on Native River @ 66/1
Spectre - ?5 win on Oscar Whiskey @ 66/1
Spectre - ?5 win on Birds Nest @ 80/1
Nortonscoin200 - ?5 win on OverTheLast @ 80/1
Imperial Commander - ?5 win on The Rowebott @ 80/1
Quevega - ?5 win on Dannycraigpirates @ 80/1
Imperial Commander - ?5 win on FatCatShat @ 100/1
Nortonscoin200 - ?5 win on Bigfish @ 100/1
Chaser1980 - ?5 win on Bigfish @ 100/1
Quevega - ?5 win on Dannycraigpirates @ 125/1
Quevega - ?5 win on Smiley @ 125/1
Big Bucks - ?2.50 E/W on Craigy14 @ 20/1
Craigy14 - ?2.50 E/W on TigerRoll @ 33/1
Can’tCatchMe - ?2.50 E/W on Craigy14 @ 33/1
Native River - ?2.50 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 40/1
ComplyOrDie - ?2.50 E/W on Captain Chris @ 50/1
Faugheen_Machine - ?2.50 E/W on Oscar Whisky @ 66/1
Craigy14 - ?2.50 E/W on Salubrious Chin @ 80/1
Joleg - ?2.50 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Jono - ?2.50 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Dandrew99 - ?2.50 E/W on Lobos @ 80/1
Joleg - ?2.50 E/W on Birds Nest @ 80/1
Jono - ?2.50 E/W on Bigfish @ 100/1
Can’tCatchMe - ?2.50 E/W on Bigfish @ 100/1
Jonthehammer - ?4 win on Scooby @ 8/1
RufusFlynn - ?4 win on Al Boum Photo @ 16/1
RufusFlynn - ?2 E/W on Captain Chris @ 50/1
Dandrew99 - ?2 E/W on TheKingPimm @ 66/1
Native River - ?2 E/W on TheKingPimm @ 66/1
Dandrew99 - ?2 E/W on Oscar Whisky @ 66/1
Kevloaf - ?2 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Jorvik - ?2 E/W on Bigfish @ 100/1
Native River - ?2 E/W on Green Goddess @ 100/1
Jorvik - ?3 win on Quevega @ 14/1
Jorvik - ?3 win on Tiger Rolll @ 33/1
Jonthehammer - ?1.50 E/W on Charlie @ 14/1
Jonthehammer - ?1.50 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Kevloaf - ?1.50 E/W on Bigfish @ 100/1
Kevloaf - ?1.50 E/W on Dannycraigpirates @ 125/1
Faugheen_Machine - ?2.50 win on Middle_Of_March @ 22/1
Ryan97 - ?2.50 win on SharpHat @ 25/1
TheKingPimm - ?2.50 win on Crolwey113 @ 28/1
TheKingPimm - ?2.50 win on Can’tCatchMe
Ryan97 - ?2.50 win on Tiger Rolll @ 33/1
Al Boum Photo - ?1.25 E/W on SharpHat @ 25/1
Al Boum Photo - ?1.25 E/W on Crolwey113 @ 28/1
Al Boum Photo - ?1.25 E/W on Bigfish @ 100/1
Faugheen_Machine - ?1.25 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Al Boum Photo - ?1.25 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Native River - ?2 win on Quevega @ 14/1
Big Bucks - ?1 E/W on Jorvik @ 18/1
Istabraq - ?1 E/W on BigBucks @ 40/1
Dandrew99 - ?1 E/W on Dandrew99 @ 80/1
Istabraq - ?1 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
Big Bucks - ?1 E/W on Jonthehammer @ 80/1
RufusFlynn - ?1 E/W on RufusFlynn @ 80/1



Just a note, I have voided bets on the Fish as a goodwill gesture as he only managed to survive two games before his ban.
Click to expand...
One last one. That last line has made me chuckle as well. Giving out f**king goodwill gestures for anyone who backed the 125/1 shot who got himself banned two matches into the comp :ROFLMAO:

It’s hardly a shock in hindsight that I would go on to be an odds compiler a few years later is it.
 
Middle_Of_March said:
This has chuckled me too.

F**k it.. I will 100% be bringing both competitions back for between December and February. With the actual tipping comp to be starting on the New Years Day card at Cheltenham on January 1st.
Click to expand...
Fair play @Middle_Of_March. Looking forward to it already. Shame we never got to know who won the DG Cup 2025
 
Absolutely buzzing for this MOM! I hope the fish reappears with a suitable pseudonym in time to take part
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevloaf
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom